https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7945 Site Page Home 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit.aoshearman.com/attorneys 2017-11-27 1.0 7947 Site Page Contacts 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ 2018-01-12 1.0 7959 Site Page IP Litigation 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/blogdetail 2017-11-20 0.8 7963 Site Page 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7973 Site Page About 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-sl.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7974 Site Page Securities Litigation 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-wc.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7975 Site Page Government/Regulatory Enforcement 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ma.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7976 Site Page M%26A and Corporate Governance 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-antitrust.aoshearman.com/ 2017-11-20 1.0 7977 Site Page Antitrust Litigation 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/us-court-of-appeals-for-the-federal-circuit-clari 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog U.S. Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Clarifies Venue Law For Pre-Heartland Patent Cases %26nbsp; 4475 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-announces-ipr-reman 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Announces IPR Remand Procedures 4479 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/united-states-patent-office-adopts-rule-on-attorn 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog United States Patent Office Adopts Rule On Attorney-Client Privilege %26nbsp; 4516 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20042/37 C.F.R. 42.57.pdf File: United States Patent Office Adopts Rule On Attorney-Client Privilege %26nbsp; file 13376 4516 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/check-processing-invention-found-patent-eligiblen 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Check-Processing Invention Found Patent-Eligible %26nbsp; 4517 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20043/Soultran, Inc. v. U.S. Bancorp, Case No. 13-cv-2637.pdf File: Check-Processing Invention Found Patent-Eligible %26nbsp; file 13376 4517 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/us-supreme-court-reviews-inter-partes-review-in-o 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog U.S. Supreme Court Reviews Inter Partes Review In Oil States And SAS Oral Arguments%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 4518 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/suppliersrsquo-intervention-in-retailer-suit-prev 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Suppliers%26rsquo; Intervention In Retailer Suit Previews Post-T.C. Heartland Venue Disputes %26nbsp; 4568 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-grants-motion-for-modified-protective-order- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Grants Motion For Modified Protective Order To Prevent Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Expert-Witness/CEO From Accessing Petitioner%26rsquo;s Highly-Confidential Documents %26nbsp; 4601 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20243/IPR2017-00091, No. 56 Order - Decision Granting Petitioners Motion for Protective Order (USPTO Dec. 13, 2017).pdf File: PTAB Grants Motion For Modified Protective Order To Prevent Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Expert-Witness/CEO From Accessing Petitioner%26rsquo;s Highly-Confidential Documents %26nbsp; file 13376 4601 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-denies-joint-motion-to-terminate-due-to-sett 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Denies Joint Motion To Terminate Due To Settlement Sought Just Prior To Final Written Decision Deadline%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 4602 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20244/IPR2016-01187, No. 100 Order - Decision Denying Joint Motion to Terminate (USPTO Dec. 14, 2017).pdf File: PTAB Denies Joint Motion To Terminate Due To Settlement Sought Just Prior To Final Written Decision Deadline%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 4602 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-magistrate-judge-recommends- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Magistrate Judge Recommends Denial Of Amazon%26rsquo;s Section 101 Motion To Dismiss %26nbsp; 4603 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20245/M2M Solutions LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., 1_17-cv-00202, No. 47 (D.Del. Dec. 11, 2017).pdf File: District Of Delaware Magistrate Judge Recommends Denial Of Amazon%26rsquo;s Section 101 Motion To Dismiss %26nbsp; file 13376 4603 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-orders-production-of-expert- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Orders Production Of Expert Materials Over FRCP 26(a)(2)(B), 26(b)(4)(B), And Work Product Objections %26nbsp; 4604 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2017-12-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20246/Ansell Healthcare Products LLC v. Reckitt Benckiser LLC, 1_15-cv-00915 (D. Del. Dec. 11, 2017).pdf File: District Of Delaware Orders Production Of Expert Materials Over FRCP 26(a)(2)(B), 26(b)(4)(B), And Work Product Objections %26nbsp; file 13376 4604 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/massachusetts-district-court-declines-to-compel-i 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Massachusetts District Court Declines To Compel Inventor Testimony %26nbsp; 4695 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20499/Koninklijke Philips N.V. et al v. Wangs Alliance Corporation, 1_14-cv-12298, No. 226 (D.Mass. Jan. 2, 2018).pdf File: Massachusetts District Court Declines To Compel Inventor Testimony %26nbsp; file 13376 4695 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-wisconsin-upholds-juryrsquos- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of Wisconsin Upholds Jury%26rsquo;s Willful-Infringement Finding And Awards Prejudgment Interest, But Declines To Enhance Damages; Employee Engineer%26rsquo;s Invalidity Analysis An Issue %26nbsp; 4696 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20500/Milwaukee Electric Tool Corporation et al v. Snap-On Incorporated, 2_14-cv-01296, No. 372 (E.D.Wis. Dec. 29, 2017).pdf File: Eastern District Of Wisconsin Upholds Jury%26rsquo;s Willful-Infringement Finding And Awards Prejudgment Interest, But Declines To Enhance Damages; Employee Engineer%26rsquo;s Invalidity Analysis An Issue %26nbsp; file 13376 4696 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-computer-security-method-pa 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Computer Security Method Patentable, But Overturns Damages Award%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 4734 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20568/Finjan, Inc. v. Blue Coat Systems.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Computer Security Method Patentable, But Overturns Damages Award%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 4734 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-bars-second-patent-suit-under-claim-preclus 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Court Bars Second Patent Suit Under Claim-Preclusion Doctrine%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 4735 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20569/XY, LLC v. Trans Ova Genetics, LC.pdf File: Court Bars Second Patent Suit Under Claim-Preclusion Doctrine%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 4735 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-that-obligation-to-assign 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms That Obligation-To-Assign Term In Employment Agreement Is Not Sufficient To Give Employer Standing To Sue For Infringement %26nbsp; 4762 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20673/Advanced Video Technologies, Inc. v. HTC Corp., et al., No. 2016-2309 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 11, 2018).PDF File: Federal Circuit Affirms That Obligation-To-Assign Term In Employment Agreement Is Not Sufficient To Give Employer Standing To Sue For Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 4762 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-upholds-texas-trial-court-on-sect 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Upholds Texas Trial Court On Section 101 And On Claim-Construction Burden-Of-Proof Issues, And Again Takes Appellate Jurisdiction While Damages Issues Remain Pending In The Trial Court %26nbsp; 4794 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-01-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20812/Core Wireless Licensing S.A.R.L. v. LG Electronics, Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Upholds Texas Trial Court On Section 101 And On Claim-Construction Burden-Of-Proof Issues, And Again Takes Appellate Jurisdiction While Damages Issues Remain Pending In The Trial Court %26nbsp; file 13376 4794 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-denies-discovery-on 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Denies Discovery On Real-Party-In-Interest Issue %26nbsp; 4825 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20882/Artesian Home Prods. v. Gutterglove, Inc., No. IPR2018-00015.pdf File: Patent Trial And Appeal Board Denies Discovery On Real-Party-In-Interest Issue %26nbsp; file 13376 4825 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ninth-circuit-holds-copyright-in-drawing-of-dolphins 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Ninth Circuit Holds Copyright In Drawing Of Dolphins Not Infringed, Even If Drawing Copied %26nbsp; 4826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20883/Folkens v. Wyland Worldwide, No. 16-15882 (9th Cir. Feb. 2, 2018).pdf File: Ninth Circuit Holds Copyright In Drawing Of Dolphins Not Infringed, Even If Drawing Copied %26nbsp; file 13376 4826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-awaits-ruling-from-court 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Awaits Ruling From Bankruptcy Court On Automatic-Stay Provision %26nbsp; 4827 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20884/Twitter, Inc. v. Youtoo Techs., LLC, Case No. IPR2017-00829.pdf File: Patent Trial And Appeal Board Awaits Ruling From Bankruptcy Court On Automatic-Stay Provision %26nbsp; file 13376 4827 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-transfers-walker-process-appeal-to-regional 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Transfers Walker Process Appeal To Regional Circuit %26nbsp; 4846 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/20929/Xitronix Corp. v. KLA-Tencor Corp., ___ F.3d ___ (appeal no. 2016-2746).pdf File: Federal Circuit Transfers Walker Process Appeal To Regional Circuit %26nbsp; file 13376 4846 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-waves-caution-flag-on-section-101 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Waves Caution Flag On Section 101 %26nbsp; 4879 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21026/Berkheimer v. HP.pdf File: Federal Circuit Waves Caution Flag On Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 4879 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-dismisses-trade-dress-complaint-on 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Dismisses Trade-Dress Complaint On Multiple Grounds%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 4902 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-02-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21058/Eliya Inc. v. Steve Madden, Ltd., No. 215-CV-1272 (E.D.N.Y. Feb. 22, 2018).pdf File: District Court Dismisses Trade-Dress Complaint On Multiple Grounds%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 4902 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/delaware-court-finds-industrial-invention-unpatentable-section-101 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Delaware Court Finds Industrial Invention Unpatentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 4923 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-03-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21105/American Axle %26 Mfg. v. Neapco Drivelines LLC, 15-CV-1168 (February 27, 2018).pdf File: Delaware Court Finds Industrial Invention Unpatentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 4923 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-no-written-description-in-g 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds No Written Description In Genus/Species Disclosure Case %26nbsp; 4948 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-03-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21174/Knowles Electronics LLC v. Cirrus Logic, Inc., appeal no. 2016-2010 (March 1, 2018).PDF File: Federal Circuit Finds No Written Description In Genus/Species Disclosure Case %26nbsp; file 13376 4948 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/in-ipr-appeal-federal-circuit-holds-that-collatertal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog In IPR Appeal, Federal Circuit Holds That Collateral Estoppel Arises From Prior Claim-Construction Ruling %26nbsp; 4999 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-03-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21353/Nestle USA, Inc. v. Steuben Foods, Inc., appeal no. 2017-1193.PDF File: In IPR Appeal, Federal Circuit Holds That Collateral Estoppel Arises From Prior Claim-Construction Ruling %26nbsp; file 13376 4999 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-sufficient-written-descript 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Sufficient Written Description In Species/Genus Disclosure Case %26nbsp; 5000 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-03-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21354/Hologic, Inc. v. Smith %26 Nephew, Inc., appeal no. 2017-1389.PDF File: Federal Circuit Finds Sufficient Written Description In Species/Genus Disclosure Case %26nbsp; file 13376 5000 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-argues-over-ipr-appeal-procedure 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Argues Over IPR Appeal Procedure %26nbsp; 5048 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-03-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21520/DSS Technology Management v. Apple Inc., 16-2523 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 23, 2018).pdf File: Federal Circuit Argues Over IPR Appeal Procedure %26nbsp; file 13376 5048 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-grants-judgment-of-patent-invalidity 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Grants Judgment Of Patent Invalidity On The Pleadings, Finding Insufficient Allegations Of Validity In Complaint %26nbsp; 5091 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21662/Triplay, Inc. v. WhatsApp, Inc., No. 13-1703 (D. Del. Mar. 27, 2018).pdf File: District Court Grants Judgment Of Patent Invalidity On The Pleadings, Finding Insufficient Allegations Of Validity In Complaint %26nbsp; file 13376 5091 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/in-split-opinion-federal-circuit-holds-pto-has-st 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog In Split Opinion, Federal Circuit Holds PTO Has Standing To Proceed Without Patent Challenger, As Sole Party Defending PTAB Inter Partes Invalidity Decision 5121 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21779/Knowles Elec. LLC v. Iancu.pdf File: In Split Opinion, Federal Circuit Holds PTO Has Standing To Proceed Without Patent Challenger, As Sole Party Defending PTAB Inter Partes Invalidity Decision file 13376 5121 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/itc-alj-permits-evidence-of-post-complaint-domestic 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog ITC ALJ Permits Evidence Of Post-Complaint Domestic Industry %26nbsp; 5161 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21921/Certain Digital Cameras, Software, and Components Thereof, 337-1059, No. 641181-1 (U.S.I.T.C. Apr. 5, 2018).pdf File: ITC ALJ Permits Evidence Of Post-Complaint Domestic Industry %26nbsp; file 13376 5161 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-hears-oral-argument-in-key-patent-damages 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument In Key Patent Damages Case %26nbsp; 5193 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/21982/WesternGeco LLC v. ION Geophysical Corporation.pdf File: Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument In Key Patent Damages Case %26nbsp; file 13376 5193 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/us-supreme-court-approves-iprs-but-requires-decision 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog US Supreme Court Approves IPRS, But Requires Decision On All Challenged Claims %26nbsp; 5225 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22030/Oil States Opinion 16-712.pdf File: US Supreme Court Approves IPRS, But Requires Decision On All Challenged Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 5225 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-04-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22031/SAS Institute Opinion 16-969.pdf File: US Supreme Court Approves IPRS, But Requires Decision On All Challenged Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 5225 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-there-is-no-right-to-a 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That There Is No Right To A Jury Trial On A Claim For Disgorgement As A Remedy For Trade Secret Misappropriation %26nbsp; 5249 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22066/Texas Advanced Optoelectronic Solutions, Inc., 2016-2121 (Fed. Cir. May 1, 2018).pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That There Is No Right To A Jury Trial On A Claim For Disgorgement As A Remedy For Trade Secret Misappropriation %26nbsp; file 13376 5249 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-issues-proposed-rulemaking-to-adopt-district 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Issues Proposed Rulemaking To Adopt District-Court Claim Construction Standard For AIA Trial Proceedings %26nbsp; 5285 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22116/83 FR 21221 (May 9, 2018).pdf File: USPTO Issues Proposed Rulemaking To Adopt District-Court Claim Construction Standard For AIA Trial Proceedings %26nbsp; file 13376 5285 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-continues-to-clarify-patent-venue 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Continues To Clarify Patent Venue Rules In The Wake Of The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s TC Heartland Decision%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 5305 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22178/In re HTC Corporation, 2018-130 (May 9, 2018).PDF File: Federal Circuit Continues To Clarify Patent Venue Rules In The Wake Of The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s TC Heartland Decision%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 5305 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22179/In re ZTE (USA) Inc., 2018-113 (May 14, 2018).PDF File: Federal Circuit Continues To Clarify Patent Venue Rules In The Wake Of The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s TC Heartland Decision%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 5305 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22180/In re Bigcommerce, Inc., 2018-120 (May 15, 2018).PDF File: Federal Circuit Continues To Clarify Patent Venue Rules In The Wake Of The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s TC Heartland Decision%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 5305 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-notice-printed-in-surgical-guide-ruled-insufficient 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Notice Printed In Surgical Guide Ruled Insufficient Marking Of Patented Surgical Implant %26nbsp; 5322 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-05-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22223/Acantha LLC v. DePuy Orthopaedics Inc et al, 1_15-cv-01257, No. 253 (E.D.Wis. May. 19, 2018).pdf File: Patent Notice Printed In Surgical Guide Ruled Insufficient Marking Of Patented Surgical Implant %26nbsp; file 13376 5322 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-emphasizes-factual-nature-of-section 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Emphasizes Factual Nature Of Section 101 Determinations %26nbsp; 5349 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-06-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22296/Berkheimer v. HP Inc., Appeal No. 2017-1437.pdf File: Federal Circuit Emphasizes Factual Nature Of Section 101 Determinations %26nbsp; file 13376 5349 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-designates-as-precedential 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Designates As Precedential Opinion Instructing On Claim Amendments. 5384 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-06-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22388/Western Digital v. SPEX Techs., Case No. IPR2018-00082, paper no. 13 (April 25, 2018).pdf File: Patent Trial And Appeal Board Designates As Precedential Opinion Instructing On Claim Amendments. file 13376 5384 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/exceptional-case-attorneys-fees-denied 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Recovery Of %26ldquo;Exceptional Case Attorneys%26rdquo; Fees Denied Because Wronged Party Delayed In Making Its Position Clear 5399 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-06-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22488/6 - IP - Stone Basket Innovations v Cook Medical LLC, No. 2017-2330 (Fed. Cir. June 11, 2018).pdf File: Recovery Of %26ldquo;Exceptional Case Attorneys%26rdquo; Fees Denied Because Wronged Party Delayed In Making Its Position Clear file 13376 5399 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-reverses-federal-circuit-and-holds 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Reverses Federal Circuit And Holds That Patent-Infringement Damages Suffered Overseas May Be Recoverable Under U.S. Patent Law 5442 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-06-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22660/9 IP - Westerngeco v Ion - SCT opinion.pdf File: Supreme Court Reverses Federal Circuit And Holds That Patent-Infringement Damages Suffered Overseas May Be Recoverable Under U.S. Patent Law file 13376 5442 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-expands-the-supreme-courts 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Expands The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s SAS Holding To Require Institution On All Grounds Argued In An IPR Petition %26nbsp; 5500 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-07-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22765/9 - Adidas v. Nike, 2018-1180 (Fed. Cir. July 2, 2018) (Motion Panel Order).pdf File: Federal Circuit Expands The Supreme Court%26rsquo;s SAS Holding To Require Institution On All Grounds Argued In An IPR Petition %26nbsp; file 13376 5500 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-enhanced-damages-award 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Enhanced Damages Award %26nbsp; 5535 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-07-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/22838/Polara Eng. Inc. v. Campbell Co. (IP).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Enhanced Damages Award %26nbsp; file 13376 5535 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-indian-tribes-sovereign-immunity-argument 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects Indian Tribe%26rsquo;s %26ldquo;Sovereign Immunity%26rdquo; Argument Regarding A Validity Challenge To A Patent It Acquired From Allergan, Inc. %26nbsp; 5606 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-07-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23054/Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe et al. v. Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc. et al (IP).pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects Indian Tribe%26rsquo;s %26ldquo;Sovereign Immunity%26rdquo; Argument Regarding A Validity Challenge To A Patent It Acquired From Allergan, Inc. %26nbsp; file 13376 5606 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-considers-whether-rpx-client 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Considers Whether RPX Client Is A Real Party-In-Interest To RPX IPRs %26nbsp; 5645 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-07-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23107/Applications in Internet Time, LLC v. RPX Corp. (IP).pdf File: Federal Circuit Considers Whether RPX Client Is A Real Party-In-Interest To RPX IPRs %26nbsp; file 13376 5645 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rules-on-issue-of-prosecution-history 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rules On Issue Of Prosecution-History Estoppel In Design-Patent Case %26nbsp; 5681 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-08-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23183/Shanghai Walk-Long Tools.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rules On Issue Of Prosecution-History Estoppel In Design-Patent Case %26nbsp; file 13376 5681 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-dismisses-ipr-appeal-for-lack-of-standing 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Dismisses IPR Appeal For Lack Of Standing %26nbsp; 5719 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-08-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23299/Jtekt v. GKN (IP).pdf File: Federal Circuit Dismisses IPR Appeal For Lack Of Standing %26nbsp; file 13376 5719 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-mandamus-petition 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Mandamus Petition Regarding IPR Institution Decision %26nbsp; 6739 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-08-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23414/In re Power Integrations, Inc., Petitioner (IP).pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Mandamus Petition Regarding IPR Institution Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 6739 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/en-banc-federal-circuit-holds-that-dismissal-without 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog En Banc Federal Circuit Holds That Dismissal Without Prejudice Of District Court Action Does Not Reset IPR Time-Bar Clock %26nbsp; 6741 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-08-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23416/Click-To-Call Technologies, LP, Appelant v. Ingenio, Inc., Yellowpages.com, LLC, Appellees (IP).pdf File: En Banc Federal Circuit Holds That Dismissal Without Prejudice Of District Court Action Does Not Reset IPR Time-Bar Clock %26nbsp; file 13376 6741 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-ptab-rejection-of-design 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Rejection Of Design Patent Application %26nbsp; 6758 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-08-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23468/In re. Ron Maatita.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Rejection Of Design Patent Application %26nbsp; file 13376 6758 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-judgment-of-patent-claim-indefiniteness 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Judgment Of Patent Claim Indefiniteness %26nbsp; 6802 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-09-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23685/Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. T-Mobile USA, Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Judgment Of Patent Claim Indefiniteness %26nbsp; file 13376 6802 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-exercises-its-discretion-to-deny-inter-partes-review-institution 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Exercises Its Discretion To Deny Inter Partes Review Institution Because Of The Advanced Stage Of Parallel District Court Litigation %26nbsp; 6834 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-09-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23819/NHK Spring Co., LTD., Petitioner v. Intri-Plex Technologies, Inc..pdf File: PTAB Exercises Its Discretion To Deny Inter Partes Review Institution Because Of The Advanced Stage Of Parallel District Court Litigation %26nbsp; file 13376 6834 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-ptab-finding-of-patentability 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Finding Of Patentability %26nbsp; 6850 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-09-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/23908/E.I. du Pont de Nemours %26 Co. v. Synvina C.V..pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Finding Of Patentability %26nbsp; file 13376 6850 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-award-of-attorneys 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees In NPE Patent Case %26nbsp; 6890 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-10-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24098/17-2414.Opinion.9-28-2018 - Gust v Alphacap Ventures.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees In NPE Patent Case %26nbsp; file 13376 6890 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-treatment-of-priority-date-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Treatment Of Priority-Date Claims %26nbsp; 6920 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-10-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24200/Natural Alternatives Int'l, Inc. v. Iancu.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Treatment Of Priority-Date Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 6920 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-issues-final-rule-adopting-district-court-claim 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Issues Final Rule Adopting District-Court Claim Construction Standard For AIA Trial Proceedings %26nbsp; 6944 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-10-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24269/Changes to the Claim Construction Standard.pdf File: USPTO Issues Final Rule Adopting District-Court Claim Construction Standard For AIA Trial Proceedings %26nbsp; file 13376 6944 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/itc-administrative-law-judge-rules-that-staff-participation-can-avoid-estoppel-effect 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog ITC Administrative Law Judge Rules That Staff Participation Can Avoid Estoppel Effect Of Respondent%26rsquo;s Earlier IPR %26nbsp; 6981 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-10-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24470/Certain Magnetic Tape Cartridges.pdf File: ITC Administrative Law Judge Rules That Staff Participation Can Avoid Estoppel Effect Of Respondent%26rsquo;s Earlier IPR %26nbsp; file 13376 6981 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-relies-on-references 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Relies On References Not Available As IPR Prior Art In Unpatentability Decision %26nbsp; 7010 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-10-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24641/C%26D Zodiac, Inc. v. BE Aerospace, Inc..pdf File: Patent Trial And Appeal Board Relies On References Not Available As IPR Prior Art In Unpatentability Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 7010 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-secondary-meaning-and-infrigement-tests-for-trade-dress 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Secondary Meaning And Infringement Tests For Trade Dress %26nbsp; 7038 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-11-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24693/16-2497.Opinion.10-30-2018.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Secondary Meaning And Infringement Tests For Trade Dress %26nbsp; file 13376 7038 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-finding-that-article-is-not-a-printed-publication 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Finding That Article Is Not A %26ldquo;Printed Publication%26rdquo; %26nbsp; 7075 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-11-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24738/Acceleration Bay, LLC v. Activision Blizzard Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Finding That Article Is Not A %26ldquo;Printed Publication%26rdquo; %26nbsp; file 13376 7075 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-finding-that-assignor-estoppel-does-not-apply-to-iprs 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Finding That Assignor Estoppel Does Not Apply To IPRs %26nbsp; 7105 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-11-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24801/Arista Networks, Inc. v. Cisco Sys., Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Finding That Assignor Estoppel Does Not Apply To IPRs %26nbsp; file 13376 7105 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-damages-award-based-on-hypothetical-freedom-to-operate-royalty-negotiation 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Damages Award Based On Hypothetical Freedom-to-Operate Royalty Negotiation %26nbsp; 7142 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-11-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/24891/16-2599.Opinion.11-19-2018.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Damages Award Based On Hypothetical Freedom-to-Operate Royalty Negotiation %26nbsp; file 13376 7142 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/youve-got-to-know-when-to-foldem-federal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog You%26rsquo;ve Got To Know When To Fold%26rsquo;em: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Folding Table Patent Case On Personal Jurisdiction Grounds %26nbsp; 7192 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-12-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/25047/Maxchief Investments Limited v. Wok %26 Pan, Ind., Inc..pdf File: You%26rsquo;ve Got To Know When To Fold%26rsquo;em: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Folding Table Patent Case On Personal Jurisdiction Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 7192 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-patent-assertion-letters-sufficient 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Patent Assertion Letters Sufficient For Personal Jurisdiction In Declaratory Judgment Action %26nbsp; 7262 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2018-12-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/25263/2018.12.07-162700-JackHenry-v-PlanoEncryption-CAFCDecision.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Patent Assertion Letters Sufficient For Personal Jurisdiction In Declaratory Judgment Action %26nbsp; file 13376 7262 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-rule-12b6-dismissal-of-wholly-functional-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal Of %26ldquo;Wholly Functional%26rdquo; Claims As Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; 8276 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-01-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26326/13. Glasswall Solutions Ltd. v. Clearswift Ltd., F.Appx (Fed. Cir. Dec. 20, 2018).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal Of %26ldquo;Wholly Functional%26rdquo; Claims As Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; file 13376 8276 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-patent-trial-and-appeal-board-reconsideration-ruling-claim-unpatentable 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Trial And Appeal Board Reconsideration Ruling That Claims Are Unpatentable On Non-Instituted Ground Not Addressed In Final Written Decision %26nbsp; 8293 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-01-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26412/AG Technologies S.A. v. Amazon.com Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Trial And Appeal Board Reconsideration Ruling That Claims Are Unpatentable On Non-Instituted Ground Not Addressed In Final Written Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 8293 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-trademark-trial 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands Trademark Trial And Appeal Board Likelihood-Of-Confusion Ruling For Failure To Consider Relevant Evidence And Argument Concerning DuPont Factor 8 %26nbsp; 8311 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-01-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26565/17-2620.Opinion.1-14-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands Trademark Trial And Appeal Board Likelihood-Of-Confusion Ruling For Failure To Consider Relevant Evidence And Argument Concerning DuPont Factor 8 %26nbsp; file 13376 8311 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-finds-that-the-aia-did-not-change-s 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Finds That The AIA Did Not Change Settled Pre-AIA Law That A %26ldquo;Secret%26rdquo; Sale May Trigger The On-Sale Bar %26nbsp; 8320 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-01-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26621/Helsinn v Teva.pdf File: Supreme Court Finds That The AIA Did Not Change Settled Pre-AIA Law That A %26ldquo;Secret%26rdquo; Sale May Trigger The On-Sale Bar %26nbsp; file 13376 8320 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-trial-and-appeal-board-exercises-discretion 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Trial And Appeal Board Exercises Discretion To Deny Institution Of An IPR Based On Insufficient Use Of Resources Where Petitioner Had Shown A Reasonable Likelihood Of Prevailing On Only A Small Fraction Of Challenged Claims And Grounds %26nbsp; 8330 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-02-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26725/PTAB Denial of Institution.pdf File: Patent Trial And Appeal Board Exercises Discretion To Deny Institution Of An IPR Based On Insufficient Use Of Resources Where Petitioner Had Shown A Reasonable Likelihood Of Prevailing On Only A Small Fraction Of Challenged Claims And Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 8330 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/united-states-district-court-for-the-eastern-district 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog United States District Court For The Eastern District Of New York Finds Patent Defendant Estopped From Asserting Invalidity Grounds That Defendant Did Not Include In Its Petition For Inter Partes Review %26nbsp; 8345 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-02-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26760/American Technical Ceramics Corp. et al v. Presidio Components, Inc., 2_....pdf File: United States District Court For The Eastern District Of New York Finds Patent Defendant Estopped From Asserting Invalidity Grounds That Defendant Did Not Include In Its Petition For Inter Partes Review %26nbsp; file 13376 8345 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-patent-trial-and-appeal-board 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Patent Trial And Appeal Board Decisions On CBM Proceedings Because the Challenged Patents Were For Technological Inventions And Thus Not Eligible For CBM Review %26nbsp; 8357 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-02-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26813/IP Opinion.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Patent Trial And Appeal Board Decisions On CBM Proceedings Because the Challenged Patents Were For Technological Inventions And Thus Not Eligible For CBM Review %26nbsp; file 13376 8357 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-grant-of-summary-judgmen 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Grant Of Summary Judgment Of Invalidity For Lack Of Written Description %26nbsp; 8372 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-02-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/26918/17-2510.Opinion.2-14-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Grant Of Summary Judgment Of Invalidity For Lack Of Written Description %26nbsp; file 13376 8372 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-rule-12b6-dismissal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal For Lack Of Patent Eligible Subject Matter Where The Computer Components Were Described In %26ldquo;Purely Functional Terms%26rdquo; %26nbsp; 8396 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-03-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27029/Florida Research Foundation, Inc. v. General Electric Company.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal For Lack Of Patent Eligible Subject Matter Where The Computer Components Were Described In %26ldquo;Purely Functional Terms%26rdquo; %26nbsp; file 13376 8396 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-holds-that-copyright-claimant-cannot-commence-litigation 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Holds That Copyright Claimant Cannot Commence Litigation Until After Copyright Office Registers The Copyright %26nbsp; 8427 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-03-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27062/1135000-1135152-fourth estate.pdf File: Supreme Court Holds That Copyright Claimant Cannot Commence Litigation Until After Copyright Office Registers The Copyright %26nbsp; file 13376 8427 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-designates-precedential-opinion-allowing-section-101-consideration 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Designates Precedential Opinion Allowing Section 101 Consideration Of Proposed Amended Claims %26nbsp; 8472 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-03-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27210/Amazon.com v. Uniloc Luxembourg.pdf File: PTAB Designates Precedential Opinion Allowing Section 101 Consideration Of Proposed Amended Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 8472 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/contradicting-us-patent-office-guidance-federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-rule 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Contradicting U.S. Patent Office Guidance, Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Ruling That Claims Are Directed To A %26ldquo;Natural Law%26rdquo; And Therefore Unpatentable %26nbsp; 8515 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-04-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27419/Cleveland Clinic opinion.pdf File: Contradicting U.S. Patent Office Guidance, Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Rule 12(b)(6) Ruling That Claims Are Directed To A %26ldquo;Natural Law%26rdquo; And Therefore Unpatentable %26nbsp; file 13376 8515 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-goes-ldquodeeperrdquo-offering-further-guidance 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Goes %26ldquo;Deeper,%26rdquo; Offering Further Guidance On Its Post-SAS Practice %26nbsp; 8532 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-04-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27562/Cuozzo Speed Techs., LLC v. Lee.pdf File: PTAB Goes %26ldquo;Deeper,%26rdquo; Offering Further Guidance On Its Post-SAS Practice %26nbsp; file 13376 8532 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-construes-use-in-commerce-requirement-of-federal-trademark-infringement 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Construes %26ldquo;Use In Commerce%26rdquo; Requirement Of Federal Trademark Infringement %26nbsp; 8543 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-04-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27600/18-1208.Opinion.4-19-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Construes %26ldquo;Use In Commerce%26rdquo; Requirement Of Federal Trademark Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 8543 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-finds-patent-claims-ineligible-under-usptors 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Finds Patent Claims Ineligible Under USPTO%26rsquo;s Revised Guidance On Section 101 %26nbsp; 8565 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-04-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27726/Fidelity Information Services v. Mirror Imaging.pdf File: PTAB Finds Patent Claims Ineligible Under USPTO%26rsquo;s Revised Guidance On Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 8565 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-exceptional-case 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Exceptional Case Finding Under Section 285 %26nbsp; 8583 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-05-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/27821/Thermolife Int’l LLC v. GNC Corp..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Exceptional Case Finding Under Section 285 %26nbsp; file 13376 8583 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-competitor-lacks-article-iii-standing-to-appeal-adverse-ipr-decision 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Competitor Lacks Article III Standing To Appeal Adverse IPR Decision %26nbsp; 8634 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-05-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28073/AVX v. Presidio.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Competitor Lacks Article III Standing To Appeal Adverse IPR Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 8634 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-summary-judgment-granted 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Summary Judgment Granted Pursuant To The Sham-Affidavit Doctrine %26nbsp; 8663 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-05-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28153/Quest Integrity USA, LLC, v. Cokebusters USA Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Summary Judgment Granted Pursuant To The Sham-Affidavit Doctrine %26nbsp; file 13376 8663 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/applying-the-doctrine-of-issue-preclusion-federal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Applying The Doctrine Of Issue Preclusion, Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Unpatentability Finding %26nbsp; 8684 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-06-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28198/Papst Licensing GmbH v Samsung.pdf File: Applying The Doctrine Of Issue Preclusion, Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Unpatentability Finding %26nbsp; file 13376 8684 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rules-that-state-sovereign-immunity-does-not-bar-iprs 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rules That State Sovereign Immunity Does Not Bar IPRs %26nbsp; 8745 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-06-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28263/Regents of the Univ. of Minn. v. LSI Corp. et al..pdf File: Federal Circuit Rules That State Sovereign Immunity Does Not Bar IPRs %26nbsp; file 13376 8745 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-will-consider-appealability-of-the-ptabs-section-315b-one-year-bar-rulings 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Will Consider Appealability Of The PTAB%26rsquo;s Section 315(b) One-Year Bar Rulings %26nbsp; 8784 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-that-direct-competitor-lack 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds That Direct Competitor Lacks Standing To Appeal Unfavorable IPR Decision %26nbsp; 8849 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-07-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28462/17-2497.Opinion.7-10-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds That Direct Competitor Lacks Standing To Appeal Unfavorable IPR Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 8849 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/itc-affirms-aljrsquos-determination-that-patent-c 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog ITC Affirms ALJ%26rsquo;s Determination That Patent Claims To An Automated Paving Machine Are Directed To Unpatentable Subject Matter %26nbsp; 8868 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-07-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28629/In the Matter of Certain Road Construction Machines and Components Thereof.pdf File: ITC Affirms ALJ%26rsquo;s Determination That Patent Claims To An Automated Paving Machine Are Directed To Unpatentable Subject Matter %26nbsp; file 13376 8868 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-summary-judgment-of-valid 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment Of Validity of Automotive-Part Design Patents, Rejecting The Argument That In The Automotive Context, The Parts%26rsquo; Aesthetic Appeal Is Functional %26nbsp; 8911 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-07-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28747/Auto. Body Parts Assoc. v. Ford Glob, Techs. 18-1613.Opinion.7-23-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment Of Validity of Automotive-Part Design Patents, Rejecting The Argument That In The Automotive Context, The Parts%26rsquo; Aesthetic Appeal Is Functional %26nbsp; file 13376 8911 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/applying-the-doctrine-of-argument-based-estoppel- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Applying The Doctrine Of Argument-Based Estoppel, Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Infringement Claims %26nbsp; 8940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-08-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28773/Amgen Inc. v. Computer Biosciences. Inc..pdf File: Applying The Doctrine Of Argument-Based Estoppel, Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Infringement Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 8940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-designates-precedential-two-additional-opini 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Designates Precedential Two Additional Opinions Regarding Discretionary Denials Of IPR Institution Under Sections 314(a) And 325(d) %26nbsp; 8961 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-08-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28822/Valve Corp. v. Elec. Scripting Prods. Inc. IPR2019-00064 00065 00085 (Paper 10).pdf File: PTAB Designates Precedential Two Additional Opinions Regarding Discretionary Denials Of IPR Institution Under Sections 314(a) And 325(d) %26nbsp; file 13376 8961 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-08-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28823/Becton, Dickinson %26 Co. v. B. Braun Melsungen AG, IPR2017-01586 (Paper 8).pdf File: PTAB Designates Precedential Two Additional Opinions Regarding Discretionary Denials Of IPR Institution Under Sections 314(a) And 325(d) %26nbsp; file 13376 8961 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-ptabrsquos-ob 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Finding Predicated On Incorrect Claim Construction %26nbsp; 8977 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-08-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28890/MTD Products Inc. v. Iancu.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Finding Predicated On Incorrect Claim Construction %26nbsp; file 13376 8977 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-dismisses-appeals-challenging-ptabs-decision-to-terminate-iprs-on-remand 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Dismisses Appeals Challenging PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision To Terminate IPRs On Remand %26nbsp; 9008 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28920/Biodelivery Sciences v. Aquestive, 19-1643 (Fed. Cir.).pdf File: Federal Circuit Dismisses Appeals Challenging PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision To Terminate IPRs On Remand %26nbsp; file 13376 9008 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-district-courts-decision-for-failing-to-construe-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands District Court%26rsquo;s Decision For Failing To Construe Claims Before Ruling On Patent Eligibility %26nbsp; 9009 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28921/MyMail v ooVoo (Fed Cir Aug. 16, 2019).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands District Court%26rsquo;s Decision For Failing To Construe Claims Before Ruling On Patent Eligibility %26nbsp; file 13376 9009 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-designates-as-precedential-decision-barring-ipr-filed-more-than-one-year-after-patent-challenge 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Designates As Precedential Decision Barring IPR Filed More Than One Year After Patent Challenger Filed District Court Action That Was Dismissed Without Prejudice %26nbsp; 9039 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28967/Cisco Systems, Inc. v. Chrimar Systems, Inc., IPR2018-01511 DDI (Paper 11).pdf File: PTAB Designates As Precedential Decision Barring IPR Filed More Than One Year After Patent Challenger Filed District Court Action That Was Dismissed Without Prejudice %26nbsp; file 13376 9039 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-designates-precedential-two-opinions-regarding-ipr-time-bar 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Designates Precedential Two Opinions Regarding IPR Time Bar And Pre-Institution Disclaimer %26nbsp; 9057 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28991/Infiltrator Water Techs v Presby Patent Trust IPR2018-00224 (Paper 18).pdf File: PTAB Designates Precedential Two Opinions Regarding IPR Time Bar And Pre-Institution Disclaimer %26nbsp; file 13376 9057 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/28992/GE v. United Tech. Corp. IPR2017-00491.pdf File: PTAB Designates Precedential Two Opinions Regarding IPR Time Bar And Pre-Institution Disclaimer %26nbsp; file 13376 9057 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-for-dismissal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands For Dismissal District Court%26rsquo;s Jurisdictional Finding That Parties%26rsquo; Claims Arose Under U.S. Patent Law %26nbsp; 9076 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29081/IP Case.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands For Dismissal District Court%26rsquo;s Jurisdictional Finding That Parties%26rsquo; Claims Arose Under U.S. Patent Law %26nbsp; file 13376 9076 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-technological-invention-exception-may-bar-cbm-review 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds %26ldquo;Technological Invention%26rdquo; Exception May Bar CBM Review %26nbsp; 9111 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-09-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29183/SIPCO LLC v Emerson Elec. Co. (Fed. Circ. Sept. 25, 2019).pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds %26ldquo;Technological Invention%26rdquo; Exception May Bar CBM Review %26nbsp; file 13376 9111 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ineligibility-of-patent-claiming- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Ineligibility Of Patent Claiming Methods For Manufacturing Automotive Components %26nbsp; 9141 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-10-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29234/18-1763.Opinion.10-3-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Ineligibility Of Patent Claiming Methods For Manufacturing Automotive Components %26nbsp; file 13376 9141 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-denies-customerrsquos-ldquofollow-onrdquo-ipr 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Denies Customer%26rsquo;s %26ldquo;Follow-On%26rdquo; IPR Petition Based On Supplier%26rsquo;s Prior Petition%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 9176 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-10-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29269/PTAB-IPR2019-00884-22.pdf File: PTAB Denies Customer%26rsquo;s %26ldquo;Follow-On%26rdquo; IPR Petition Based On Supplier%26rsquo;s Prior Petition%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 9176 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-that-patent-sublicenses-do- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds That Patent Sublicenses Do Not Automatically Terminate Upon Termination Of The Main License Agreement %26nbsp; 9191 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-10-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29283/18-2400.Opinion.10-17-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds That Patent Sublicenses Do Not Automatically Terminate Upon Termination Of The Main License Agreement %26nbsp; file 13376 9191 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-finding-that-c 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That Claims Are Not Unpatentable As Anticipated Or Obvious %26nbsp; 9203 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-10-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29326/Google LLC v. Koninklijke Philips N.V..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That Claims Are Not Unpatentable As Anticipated Or Obvious %26nbsp; file 13376 9203 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-ptabrsquos-obviousness-fi 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Finding For Failure To Consider Evidence Of Copying %26nbsp; 9222 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-11-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29422/Liqwd Inc. v. L'Oreal USA Inc., No. 18-2152 (Fed. Circ. Oct. 30, 2019).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Finding For Failure To Consider Evidence Of Copying %26nbsp; file 13376 9222 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-public-availability-of-foreign-publication 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Public Availability Of Foreign Publication %26nbsp; 9228 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-11-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29492/17-2381.Opinion.11-7-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Public Availability Of Foreign Publication %26nbsp; file 13376 9228 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-considers-analogous-art-in-obviousness-analysis 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Considers Analogous Art In Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; 9260 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-11-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29545/Otto Bock Healthcare, Docket No. 9378 (FTC Final Order).pdf File: Federal Circuit Considers Analogous Art In Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 9260 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-11-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29546/Otto Bock Healthcare, Docket No. 9378 (FTC Opinion).pdf File: Federal Circuit Considers Analogous Art In Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 9260 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-courtrsquos-grant 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Grant Of 12(c) Motion Under Section 101 Because Claims Were Not Directed To An Abstract Idea%26nbsp;%26nbsp; %26nbsp; 9285 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-11-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29607/18-1863.Opinion.11-15-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Grant Of 12(c) Motion Under Section 101 Because Claims Were Not Directed To An Abstract Idea%26nbsp;%26nbsp; %26nbsp; file 13376 9285 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-term-of-court-imposed-frand 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Term Of Court-Imposed FRAND License Violated Seventh Amendment Right To A Jury Trial %26nbsp; 9331 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-12-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29671/18-1363.Opinion.12-5-2019.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Term Of Court-Imposed FRAND License Violated Seventh Amendment Right To A Jury Trial %26nbsp; file 13376 9331 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-test-for-claim-scope-disavowal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Test For Claim Scope Disavowal %26nbsp; 9383 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2019-12-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29720/Techtronic.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Test For Claim Scope Disavowal %26nbsp; file 13376 9383 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-obviousness-of-patents-covering-extended-release-hydrocodone-formulations 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Obviousness Of Patents Covering Extended-Release Hydrocodone Formulations %26nbsp; 9408 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-01-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29774/Persion Pharmaceuticals.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Obviousness Of Patents Covering Extended-Release Hydrocodone Formulations %26nbsp; file 13376 9408 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-a-wide-scope-inquiry-into 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects A Wide Scope Inquiry Into Options Available At The Time Of Invention In An Obvious-To-Try Analysis %26nbsp; 9424 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-01-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29816/19-1234.Opinion.1-6-2020.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects A Wide Scope Inquiry Into Options Available At The Time Of Invention In An Obvious-To-Try Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 9424 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-holds-that-certain-communications- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Holds That Certain Communications Between Defendant And Non-Party Distributor Were Protected By The Common Interest Doctrine, While Other Communications That Were Primarily Business-In-Nature Were Not %26nbsp; 9465 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-01-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/29908/NDIL-1-18-cv-00825-182.pdf File: District Court Holds That Certain Communications Between Defendant And Non-Party Distributor Were Protected By The Common Interest Doctrine, While Other Communications That Were Primarily Business-In-Nature Were Not %26nbsp; file 13376 9465 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-finding-that-general 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That General Knowledge Can Supply Missing Claim Limitations In Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; 9550 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-02-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30006/Koninklijke Philips NV v. Google LLC et al., case number 19-1177.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That General Knowledge Can Supply Missing Claim Limitations In Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 9550 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-denies-motion-to-dismiss-infectious 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Denies Motion To Dismiss Infectious Unenforceability Counterclaims %26nbsp; 9578 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-02-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30054/District Of Delaware Denies Motion To Dismiss Infectious-Unenforceability Counterclaims.pdf File: District Of Delaware Denies Motion To Dismiss Infectious Unenforceability Counterclaims %26nbsp; file 13376 9578 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-presence-of-googlersquos-ca 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Presence Of Google%26rsquo;s Cache Servers In The Eastern District Of Texas Does Not Justify Venue %26nbsp; 9786 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-02-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30181/In re Google 19-126.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Presence Of Google%26rsquo;s Cache Servers In The Eastern District Of Texas Does Not Justify Venue %26nbsp; file 13376 9786 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-that-cessation-of-sales-of-unmarked-patented-articles 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds That Cessation Of Sales Of Unmarked Patented Articles Does Not Excuse Noncompliance With The Statutory Notice Requirement %26nbsp; 9806 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-03-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30230/Arctic Cat v. Bombardier.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds That Cessation Of Sales Of Unmarked Patented Articles Does Not Excuse Noncompliance With The Statutory Notice Requirement %26nbsp; file 13376 9806 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-final-written-decision 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Final Written Decision Holding Advertising Patent Claims Unpatentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 9816 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-03-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30269/18-2239.Opinion.3-6-2020_1546270.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Final Written Decision Holding Advertising Patent Claims Unpatentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 9816 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-rejects-plaintiffrsquos-law- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Rejects Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Law-Of-The-Case Argument And Grants Motion For Judgment On The Pleadings Based On Patent-Ineligible Subject Matter %26nbsp; 9826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-03-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30296/DDE-1-17-cv-01041-375.pdf File: District Of Delaware Rejects Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Law-Of-The-Case Argument And Grants Motion For Judgment On The Pleadings Based On Patent-Ineligible Subject Matter %26nbsp; file 13376 9826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/update-on-key-patent-court-scheduling-adjustments 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Update On Key Patent Court Scheduling Adjustments In View Of COVID-19 %26nbsp; 9835 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-that-35-usc-sect-315c-does-not-permit-new-party 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds That 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(c) Does Not Permit New-Party Or New-Issue Joinder In IPR Proceedings %26nbsp; 9864 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-03-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30437/20-03-18_Facebook-v-WindyCityInnovations_PATO_Obviousness.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds That 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(c) Does Not Permit New-Party Or New-Issue Joinder In IPR Proceedings %26nbsp; file 13376 9864 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-patentee-to-its-choice-during-prosecution 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds Patentee To Its Choice During Prosecution, Invalidating Key Patents %26nbsp; 9882 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-04-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/30505/19-1263.Opinion.3-26-2020_1558079.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds Patentee To Its Choice During Prosecution, Invalidating Key Patents %26nbsp; file 13376 9882 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/itc-alj-finds-inequitable-conduct-in-patent-office-renders-patent-unenforceable 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog ITC ALJ Finds Inequitable Conduct In Patent Office Renders Patent Unenforceable %26nbsp; 9903 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-04-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31563/In the Matter of Certain Child Carriers and Components Thereof.pdf File: ITC ALJ Finds Inequitable Conduct In Patent Office Renders Patent Unenforceable %26nbsp; file 13376 9903 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-eastern-district-of-texas-decision-holding-patent-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Eastern District Of Texas Decision Holding Patent Claims Patentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 9944 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-04-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31654/20-04-14_EricssonInc-v-TCLCommunicationTechnology_Alice.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Eastern District Of Texas Decision Holding Patent Claims Patentable Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 9944 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-holds-ptab-time-bar-decision-is-not-appealable 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Holds PTAB Time-Bar Decision Is Not Appealable %26nbsp; 9964 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-04-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31718/18-916_f2ah.pdf File: Supreme Court Holds PTAB Time-Bar Decision Is Not Appealable %26nbsp; file 13376 9964 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-dismisses-ipr-appeal-for-petitioners-lack-of-article 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Dismisses IPR Appeal For Petitioner%26rsquo;s Lack Of Article III Standing %26nbsp; 9982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-05-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31758/20-04-23_ArgentumPharmaceuticals-v-NovartisPharmaceuticals_PATO_Jurisdiction-Standing.pdf File: Federal Circuit Dismisses IPR Appeal For Petitioner%26rsquo;s Lack Of Article III Standing %26nbsp; file 13376 9982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-the-filing-of-an-ipr-petition-results 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That The Filing Of An IPR Petition Results In A Waiver Of Appointments Clause Challenges %26nbsp; 9993 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-05-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31811/19-2117.Motion_Panel_Order.5-5-2020.2_1582519.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That The Filing Of An IPR Petition Results In A Waiver Of Appointments Clause Challenges %26nbsp; file 13376 9993 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-refusal-to-import-limitation 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Refusal To Import Limitation, And Finding Of Obviousness %26nbsp; 10019 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-05-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31906/Lone Star Silicon Innovations LLC v. Iancu.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Refusal To Import Limitation, And Finding Of Obviousness %26nbsp; file 13376 10019 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-obviousness-decision-and-finds-challenge 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Decision And Finds Challenge To %26ldquo;Real Party In Interest%26rdquo; Requirement Non-Appealable %26nbsp; 10030 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-05-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31935/Puzhen Life USA.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Decision And Finds Challenge To %26ldquo;Real Party In Interest%26rdquo; Requirement Non-Appealable %26nbsp; file 13376 10030 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-institutes-ipr-despite-primary-references-having-been-considered 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Institutes IPR, Despite Primary References Having Been Considered During Original Patent Prosecution %26nbsp; 10067 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-06-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/31993/Medacta USA, Inc. v. RSB Spine, LLC.pdf File: PTAB Institutes IPR, Despite Primary References Having Been Considered During Original Patent Prosecution %26nbsp; file 13376 10067 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/southern-district-of-new-york-grants-motion-to-dismiss-patent-and-trade-secret-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Southern District Of New York Grants Motion To Dismiss Patent And Trade Secret Claims, Finding Patents Ineligible Under Section 101 And That Trade Secret Claim Failed To Identify A Protectable Secret %26nbsp; 10091 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-06-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32027/Stoncastle.pdf File: Southern District Of New York Grants Motion To Dismiss Patent And Trade Secret Claims, Finding Patents Ineligible Under Section 101 And That Trade Secret Claim Failed To Identify A Protectable Secret %26nbsp; file 13376 10091 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-fees-award-for-failure-to-meet-the-threshold 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Fees Award For Failure To Meet The Threshold For Exceptional Case %26nbsp; 10104 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-06-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32048/20-06-08_MunchkinInc-v-LuvNCare_Infringement_Trade-Dress_Trademark.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Fees Award For Failure To Meet The Threshold For Exceptional Case %26nbsp; file 13376 10104 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-grants-petition-for-review-despite-overlap-with-earlier-filed-petitions 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Grants Petition For Review Despite Overlap With Earlier Filed Petitions And Advanced Stage Of Parallel Litigation %26nbsp; 10143 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-06-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32127/LG v Bell ipr2020-00319.pdf File: PTAB Grants Petition For Review Despite Overlap With Earlier Filed Petitions And Advanced Stage Of Parallel Litigation %26nbsp; file 13376 10143 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-district-courts-denial-of-attorney-fees 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates District Court%26rsquo;s Denial Of Attorney Fees Following Judgment Of Patent Invalidity Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 10161 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-07-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32151/20-07-01_ ElectronicCommunication-v-Shopperschoice_Alice.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates District Court%26rsquo;s Denial Of Attorney Fees Following Judgment Of Patent Invalidity Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 10161 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-expands-arthrex-to-ex-parte-appeals-from-original-prosecution 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Expands Arthrex%26nbsp; To Ex Parte%26nbsp;%26nbsp;Appeals From Original Prosecution %26nbsp; 10187 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-07-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32187/19-2349.ORDER.7-7-2020_1614897.pdf File: Federal Circuit Expands Arthrex%26nbsp; To Ex Parte%26nbsp;%26nbsp;Appeals From Original Prosecution %26nbsp; file 13376 10187 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-rules-that-plaintiff-must-plead-facts-beyond-mere-knowledge 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Rules That Plaintiff Must Plead Facts Beyond Mere Knowledge In Complaint For Willful Infringement %26nbsp; 10219 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-07-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32267/MMT v. Volkswagen_MTD Opinion.pdf File: District Court Rules That Plaintiff Must Plead Facts Beyond Mere Knowledge In Complaint For Willful Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 10219 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-patent-owners-substitute-claims-presented-during-ipr 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Substitute Claims Presented During IPR Are Subject To A Full Examination %26nbsp; 10244 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-07-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32325/2020-07-22_Uniloc2017LLC-v-HuluLLC_PATO_Alice.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Substitute Claims Presented During IPR Are Subject To A Full Examination %26nbsp; file 13376 10244 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-directs-transfer-of-patent-suit-from-western-district-of-texas 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Directs Transfer Of Patent Suit From Western District Of Texas To Northern District Of California %26nbsp; 10270 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-08-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32441/Adobe_20-126.ORDER.7-28-2020.pdf File: Federal Circuit Directs Transfer Of Patent Suit From Western District Of Texas To Northern District Of California %26nbsp; file 13376 10270 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/doctrine-of-equivalents-cannot-be-used-to-extend-patent-claims-to-cover-software 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Doctrine Of Equivalents Cannot Be Used To Extend Patent Claims To Cover Software Where Claims Require A Physical Component %26nbsp; 10284 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-08-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32509/LightHouse Consulting - WDTX-6-19-cv-00608-39_WDTX-6-19-cv-00605-36_WDTX-6-19-cv-00594-48.pdf File: Doctrine Of Equivalents Cannot Be Used To Extend Patent Claims To Cover Software Where Claims Require A Physical Component %26nbsp; file 13376 10284 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-courtrsquos-dismissal-of-declaratory-judgment-suit 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Declaratory Judgment Suit Challenging The Constitutionality Of Retroactive Application Of Inter Partes Review %26nbsp; 10297 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-08-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32542/Security People, Inc. v. Iancu, __ F.3d __ (Aug. 20, 2020).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Declaratory Judgment Suit Challenging The Constitutionality Of Retroactive Application Of Inter Partes Review %26nbsp; file 13376 10297 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-office-issues-binding-memorandum-concerning-use-of-applicant 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Office Issues Binding Memorandum Concerning Use Of Applicant Admitted Prior Art In Inter Partes Review Proceedings %26nbsp; 10314 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-09-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32576/signed_aapa_guidance_memo.pdf File: Patent Office Issues Binding Memorandum Concerning Use Of Applicant Admitted Prior Art In Inter Partes Review Proceedings %26nbsp; file 13376 10314 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-courts-claim-construction-due-to-improper-reading 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Due To Improper Reading Of Intrinsic Evidence %26nbsp; 10481 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-09-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32708/19-1527-2020-08-27.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Due To Improper Reading Of Intrinsic Evidence %26nbsp; file 13376 10481 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/itc-suspends-enforcement-of-remedial-orders-pending-appeal 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog ITC Suspends Enforcement Of Remedial Orders Pending Appeal Of IPR Final Written Decision %26nbsp; 10497 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-09-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32731/Certain Unmanned Aerial Vehicles - Commn Op.pdf File: ITC Suspends Enforcement Of Remedial Orders Pending Appeal Of IPR Final Written Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 10497 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/northern-district-of-california-holds-claims-invaild 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Northern District Of California Holds Claims Invalid, Finding Them Not Directed To A Patent-Eligible Category, And Moreover Directed To An Abstract Idea %26nbsp; 10505 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-09-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32797/POLYCOM Order NDCA-3-18-cv-00510-105 (no HL).pdf File: Northern District Of California Holds Claims Invalid, Finding Them Not Directed To A Patent-Eligible Category, And Moreover Directed To An Abstract Idea %26nbsp; file 13376 10505 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-limits-scope-of-ipr-estoppel-and-vacates-claim-construction 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Limits Scope Of IPR Estoppel, And Vacates Claim Construction That Was Based On Expert Testimony %26nbsp; 10527 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-09-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32852/Network-1 Technologies, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Co., __ F.3d __ (Fed. Cir. September 24, 2020).pdf File: Federal Circuit Limits Scope Of IPR Estoppel, And Vacates Claim Construction That Was Based On Expert Testimony %26nbsp; file 13376 10527 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-claim-construction-despite-recitation 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Claim Construction, Despite Recitation Of Incorrect Legal Standard, And Concludes That Substantial Evidence Supports Its Unpatentability Findings %26nbsp; 10546 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-10-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32918/19-1301.OPINION.9-30-2020_1661452.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Claim Construction, Despite Recitation Of Incorrect Legal Standard, And Concludes That Substantial Evidence Supports Its Unpatentability Findings %26nbsp; file 13376 10546 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-institutes-ipr-over-patent-ownerrsquos-section-325d 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Institutes IPR Over Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Section 325(d) Argument That The Same Art And Arguments Were Already Considered By The Patent Office %26nbsp; 10570 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-10-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/32989/Sony v. BOT M8, LLC, USPTO (Oct. 6, 2020).pdf File: PTAB Institutes IPR Over Patent Owner%26rsquo;s Section 325(d) Argument That The Same Art And Arguments Were Already Considered By The Patent Office %26nbsp; file 13376 10570 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/northern-district-of-illinois-uses-collateral-estoppel-to-find-patents-invalid 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Northern District Of Illinois Uses Collateral Estoppel To Find Patents Invalid Based On PTAB%26rsquo;s Unpatentability Rulings On Similar Patents %26nbsp; 10602 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-10-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33033/NDIL-1-18-cv-07506-85.pdf File: Northern District Of Illinois Uses Collateral Estoppel To Find Patents Invalid Based On PTAB%26rsquo;s Unpatentability Rulings On Similar Patents %26nbsp; file 13376 10602 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/northern-district-of-california-finds-importation-of-medical-device-samples 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Northern District Of California Finds Importation Of Medical Device Samples Protected Under The Section 271(e)(1) Safe Harbor %26nbsp; 10612 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-10-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33082/Edwards LifeSciences Corp. v. Meril Life Sciences PVT.pdf File: Northern District Of California Finds Importation Of Medical Device Samples Protected Under The Section 271(e)(1) Safe Harbor %26nbsp; file 13376 10612 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-ruling-from-bench-on-patent-eligibility 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Ruling From Bench On Patent Eligibility As Insufficient To Enable Appellate Review %26nbsp; 10619 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-11-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33114/Realtime Data LLC v Reduxio Systems, Inc., 2019-2198 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 23, 2020).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Ruling From Bench On Patent Eligibility As Insufficient To Enable Appellate Review %26nbsp; file 13376 10619 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-petition-for-writ-of-mandamus 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Petition For Writ Of Mandamus Requesting It Vacate The District Court%26rsquo;s Spoliation-Based Sanctions Order %26nbsp; 10635 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-11-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33372/Ivantis Order.pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Petition For Writ Of Mandamus Requesting It Vacate The District Court%26rsquo;s Spoliation-Based Sanctions Order %26nbsp; file 13376 10635 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-articulates-rule-clarifying-relationship-between-printed-matter-doctrine 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Articulates Rule Clarifying Relationship Between %26ldquo;Printed Matter%26rdquo; Doctrine And %26ldquo;Subject Matter Eligibility%26rdquo; Under Alice %26nbsp; 10647 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-11-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33464/2020-11-10 CR Bard v. Angiodynamics.pdf File: Federal Circuit Articulates Rule Clarifying Relationship Between %26ldquo;Printed Matter%26rdquo; Doctrine And %26ldquo;Subject Matter Eligibility%26rdquo; Under Alice %26nbsp; file 13376 10647 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-denies-ipr-institution-due-to-co-pending-itc-investigation 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Denies IPR Institution Due To Co-Pending ITC Investigation %26nbsp; 10651 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-11-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33530/PTAB-IPR2020-00946-11 ITC.pdf File: PTAB Denies IPR Institution Due To Co-Pending ITC Investigation %26nbsp; file 13376 10651 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/us-district-court-for-the-northern-district-of-illnois-finds-patent-claims-related-to-hiv-dna 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog U.S. District Court For The Northern District of Illinois Finds Patent Claims Related To HIV DNA Replication To Be Patent Eligible Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 10678 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-12-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33631/Abbott Labs v. Grifols.pdf File: U.S. District Court For The Northern District of Illinois Finds Patent Claims Related To HIV DNA Replication To Be Patent Eligible Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 10678 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uk-defendantrsquos-interactive-website-insufficient-to-establish-personal-jurisdiction 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog UK Defendant%26rsquo;s Interactive Website Insufficient To Establish Personal Jurisdiction In Texas %26nbsp; 10687 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-12-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33666/TriOptima v. Quantile (EDTX).pdf File: UK Defendant%26rsquo;s Interactive Website Insufficient To Establish Personal Jurisdiction In Texas %26nbsp; file 13376 10687 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-video-signal-conversion-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Video Signal Conversion Claims Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; 10701 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2020-12-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/33763/Adaptive Streaming Inc. v. Netflix Inc., No. 2020-1310 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 14, 2020).pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Video Signal Conversion Claims Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; file 13376 10701 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/judge-alsup-partially-grants-section-285-request-for-attorneys 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Judge Alsup Partially Grants Section 285 Request For Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Due To Exceptional Nature Of Case, Lamenting %26ldquo;Standard Patent BS By Bought-And-Paid-For Experts%26rdquo; %26nbsp; 10764 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-01-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34020/1343000-1343265 (fee order).pdf File: Judge Alsup Partially Grants Section 285 Request For Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Due To Exceptional Nature Of Case, Lamenting %26ldquo;Standard Patent BS By Bought-And-Paid-For Experts%26rdquo; %26nbsp; file 13376 10764 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/central-district-of-california-finds-marking-of-product-packaging 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Central District Of California Finds Marking Of Product Packaging Insufficient Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 287. %26nbsp; 10778 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-01-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34044/CDCA-8-20-cv-00101-119.pdf File: Central District Of California Finds Marking Of Product Packaging Insufficient Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 287. %26nbsp; file 13376 10778 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/united-states-district-court-strikes-patentees-experts-testimony 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog United States District Court Strikes Patentee%26rsquo;s Expert%26rsquo;s Testimony That Contradicted The Patentee%26rsquo;s Statements Made In A Vacated Reexamination Proceeding %26nbsp; 10821 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-02-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34182/Sherwin - WDPA-2-17-cv-01023-859.pdf File: United States District Court Strikes Patentee%26rsquo;s Expert%26rsquo;s Testimony That Contradicted The Patentee%26rsquo;s Statements Made In A Vacated Reexamination Proceeding %26nbsp; file 13376 10821 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/plaintiffrsquos-refusal-to-articulate-a-hypothetitical-claim-warrants-summary-judgment 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Refusal To Articulate A Hypothetical Claim Warrants Summary Judgment Of Noninfringement Under The Doctrine Of Equivalents %26nbsp; 10845 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-02-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34265/2021-01-28 Fluidigm v. Ionpath - Order on MSJ.pdf File: Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Refusal To Articulate A Hypothetical Claim Warrants Summary Judgment Of Noninfringement Under The Doctrine Of Equivalents %26nbsp; file 13376 10845 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-02-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34266/2020-08-25 Fluidigm v. Ionpath - Order re Amended Infringement Contentions.pdf File: Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Refusal To Articulate A Hypothetical Claim Warrants Summary Judgment Of Noninfringement Under The Doctrine Of Equivalents %26nbsp; file 13376 10845 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-claim-terms-computer-and-passive-link 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Claim Terms %26ldquo;Computer%26rdquo; And %26ldquo;Passive Link%26rdquo; Indefinite %26nbsp; 10884 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-02-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34353/21-02-10, Infinity Computer v. Oki Data,_Infringement_ Indefiniteness.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Claim Terms %26ldquo;Computer%26rdquo; And %26ldquo;Passive Link%26rdquo; Indefinite %26nbsp; file 13376 10884 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabs-substitution-based-obviousness-decision 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Substitution-Based Obviousness Decision Related to Refrigerant Mixture %26nbsp; 10912 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-03-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34427/Daikin Indus. v. Chemours Co., 20-1616 (Fed. Cir. 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Substitution-Based Obviousness Decision Related to Refrigerant Mixture %26nbsp; file 13376 10912 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-user-identification-module-is-a-means-plus-function 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds %26ldquo;User Identification Module%26rdquo; Is A Means-Plus-Function Term And Invalid As Indefinite For Failing To Disclose Corresponding Structure %26nbsp; 10940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-03-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34506/20-1646.OPINION.3-2-2021_1741285.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds %26ldquo;User Identification Module%26rdquo; Is A Means-Plus-Function Term And Invalid As Indefinite For Failing To Disclose Corresponding Structure %26nbsp; file 13376 10940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabs-decision-related-to-estoppel 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision Related To Estoppel Over IPR Joined Parties And Obviousness %26nbsp; 10982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-03-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/34996/_NTKLW - Uniloc Opinion.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision Related To Estoppel Over IPR Joined Parties And Obviousness %26nbsp; file 13376 10982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/united-states-district-court-finds-that-a-retail- 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog United States District Court Finds That A Retail Store Operating Under Assumed Name Was Defendant%26rsquo;s Established Place of Business %26nbsp; 11015 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-03-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35170/Precis v. Tracfone - WDTX-6-20-cv-00303-48.pdf File: United States District Court Finds That A Retail Store Operating Under Assumed Name Was Defendant%26rsquo;s Established Place of Business %26nbsp; file 13376 11015 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-rejection-of-claims 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Rejection Of Claims Directed To More Accurate Genetic Data Interpretation As Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; 11034 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-04-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35199/21-03-25 In Re Board of Trustees Of The Leland Stanford Junior University_PATO_Ineligibility.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Rejection Of Claims Directed To More Accurate Genetic Data Interpretation As Patent Ineligible %26nbsp; file 13376 11034 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/supreme-court-finds-copying-of-computer-code-a-fair-use 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Finds Copying Of Computer Code A Fair Use %26nbsp; 11042 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-04-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35240/Googe v Oracle, ___ U.S. ___ (2021).pdf File: Supreme Court Finds Copying Of Computer Code A Fair Use %26nbsp; file 13376 11042 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabrsquos-non-obviousnes 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Non-Obviousness Decision Due To Lack Of Motivation To Combine %26nbsp; 11050 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-04-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35308/Apple Inc. v. Invt Spe LLC, Appeal No. 20-1859 (Fed. Cir. April 13, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Non-Obviousness Decision Due To Lack Of Motivation To Combine %26nbsp; file 13376 11050 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-another-petition-for-mandamus 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grants Another Petition For Mandamus Ordering Judge To Transfer A Case Out Of The Western District Of Texas On Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; 11065 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-04-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35384/21-136.ORDER.4-20-2021_1765968.pdf File: Federal Circuit Grants Another Petition For Mandamus Ordering Judge To Transfer A Case Out Of The Western District Of Texas On Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 11065 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-texas-grants-opposition-to-enhanced 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of Texas Grants Opposition To Enhanced Damages In %26ldquo;Garden-Variety%26rdquo; Patent Case %26nbsp; 11078 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-05-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35468/Wapp Tech v. Seattle Spinco.pdf File: Eastern District Of Texas Grants Opposition To Enhanced Damages In %26ldquo;Garden-Variety%26rdquo; Patent Case %26nbsp; file 13376 11078 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-setting-aside-patent-award 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Setting Aside Patent Award Where Patentee%26rsquo;s President Misrepresented His Knowledge Of Material Prior Art %26nbsp; 11129 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-05-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35659/Cap Export v. Zinus.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Setting Aside Patent Award Where Patentee%26rsquo;s President Misrepresented His Knowledge Of Material Prior Art %26nbsp; file 13376 11129 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-accused-infringers-reference-to-covid-19 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Accused Infringer%26rsquo;s Reference To Covid-19 Fight Insufficient To Undo Invalidity Verdict %26nbsp; 11149 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-05-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35735/Pacific Biosciences v. Oxford Nanopore Technologies, 20-2155 (CAFC May 11 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Accused Infringer%26rsquo;s Reference To Covid-19 Fight Insufficient To Undo Invalidity Verdict %26nbsp; file 13376 11149 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-court-dismissal-of-declaratory-judgment-action 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Declaratory Judgment Action For Lack Of Personal Jurisdiction %26nbsp; 11155 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-05-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35803/Trimble Inc. v. Perdiemco LLC (Fed. Cir. May 12, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Dismissal Of Declaratory Judgment Action For Lack Of Personal Jurisdiction %26nbsp; file 13376 11155 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/western-district-of-texas-grants-motion-to-transfer-venue 2021-06-15 0.5 13376 Blog Western District Of Texas Grants Motion To Transfer Venue On Section 1404 Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; 11168 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-06-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35825/WDTX-6-20-cv-00810-88.pdf File: Western District Of Texas Grants Motion To Transfer Venue On Section 1404 Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 11168 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-district-court-finding-of-no-prosecution-laches 2021-06-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands District Court%26rsquo;s Finding Of No Prosecution Laches Related To %26ldquo;GATT Bubble%26rdquo; Patent Applications %26nbsp; 11187 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-06-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35845/Hyatt Decision.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands District Court%26rsquo;s Finding Of No Prosecution Laches Related To %26ldquo;GATT Bubble%26rdquo; Patent Applications %26nbsp; file 13376 11187 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/internet-sales-to-forum-residents-processed-by-forum-based-payment-processing-service 2021-06-21 0.5 13376 Blog Internet Sales To Forum Residents Processed By Forum-Based Payment Processing Service Not Enough To Establish Personal Jurisdiction Over Retailer %26nbsp; 11204 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-06-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35943/Trustees of the Summers Family Trust v National Distribution Warehoue - CDCA-2-20-cv-10741-17.pdf File: Internet Sales To Forum Residents Processed By Forum-Based Payment Processing Service Not Enough To Establish Personal Jurisdiction Over Retailer %26nbsp; file 13376 11204 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-awards-fees-and-costs-incurred-in-district-court-patent-litigation 2021-06-28 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Awards Fees And Costs Incurred In District Court Patent Litigation, Related USPTO CBM Proceedings, And Related Appeals %26nbsp; 11219 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-06-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/35986/AMERANTH - SDCA-3-12-cv-00733-169.pdf File: District Court Awards Fees And Costs Incurred In District Court Patent Litigation, Related USPTO CBM Proceedings, And Related Appeals %26nbsp; file 13376 11219 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-writs-of-mandamus-ordering-transfer-of-venue 2021-07-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grants Writs Of Mandamus Ordering Transfer Of Venue %26nbsp; 11253 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-07-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36158/In re Samsung Elecs. Co., LTD, Nos. 2021-139, -140 (Fed. Cir. June 30, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Grants Writs Of Mandamus Ordering Transfer Of Venue %26nbsp; file 13376 11253 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-denies-motion-to-preclude-plaintiff-from-asserting-at-trial 2021-07-13 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Denies Motion To Preclude Plaintiff From Asserting At Trial Patent Claims Found Unpatentable By The US Patent Office%26rsquo;s Patent Trial And Appeal Board %26nbsp; 11263 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-07-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36197/DDE-1-18-cv-00172-275.pdf File: District Of Delaware Denies Motion To Preclude Plaintiff From Asserting At Trial Patent Claims Found Unpatentable By The US Patent Office%26rsquo;s Patent Trial And Appeal Board %26nbsp; file 13376 11263 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-district-court-element-by-element-infringement-pleading 2021-07-19 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds District Court%26rsquo;s Element-By-Element Infringement Pleading Standard Overly Demanding %26nbsp; 11270 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-07-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36222/BOT M8 v. Sony_Clean.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds District Court%26rsquo;s Element-By-Element Infringement Pleading Standard Overly Demanding %26nbsp; file 13376 11270 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-petition-to-transfer-case-out-of-western-texas 2021-07-28 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Petition To Transfer Case Out Of Western Texas %26nbsp; 11290 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-07-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36298/In re TCO AS (Fed. Circ 2021)-order.pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Petition To Transfer Case Out Of Western Texas %26nbsp; file 13376 11290 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-limits-expansion-of-ipr-estoppel-law 2021-08-03 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Limits Expansion Of IPR Estoppel Law %26nbsp; 11295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-08-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36337/General Access Solutions, Ltd. v. Virgin Mobile USA, L.P. et al, 2-20-cv-00007 (EDTX 2021-07-21, Order) (Robert W. Schroeder, III).pdf File: District Court Limits Expansion Of IPR Estoppel Law %26nbsp; file 13376 11295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-writ-of-mandamus-ordering-transfer-of-venue 2021-08-09 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grants Writ Of Mandamus Ordering Transfer Of Venue Based On Convenience %26nbsp; 11301 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-08-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36367/In re Hulu, LLC, Appeal No. 21-142 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 2, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Grants Writ Of Mandamus Ordering Transfer Of Venue Based On Convenience %26nbsp; file 13376 11301 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-texas-finds-patent-unenforceable-due-to-prosecution-laches 2021-08-19 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of Texas Finds Patent Unenforceable Due To Prosecution Laches %26nbsp; 11317 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-08-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36397/Personalized Media Communications, LLC v. Apple, Inc. Order.pdf File: Eastern District Of Texas Finds Patent Unenforceable Due To Prosecution Laches %26nbsp; file 13376 11317 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-finds-patent-claims-to-be-patent-ineligible-under-section-101 2021-08-25 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Finds Patent Claims To Be Patent Ineligible Under Section 101 %26nbsp; 11321 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-08-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36429/SynKloud Opinion.pdf File: District Of Delaware Finds Patent Claims To Be Patent Ineligible Under Section 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 11321 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-exclusion-of-damages-expert-royalty-rate-opinions 2021-08-30 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Exclusion Of Damages Expert%26rsquo;s Royalty Rate Opinions %26nbsp; 11331 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-08-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36446/MLC INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LLC V. MICRON TECHNOLOGY, INC., Case No. 20-1413.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Exclusion Of Damages Expert%26rsquo;s Royalty Rate Opinions %26nbsp; file 13376 11331 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-reverses-damages-award-for-sales-of-infringing-products 2021-09-09 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Reverses Damages Award For Sales Of Infringing Products Prior To Actual Notice Of Infringement %26nbsp; 11340 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-09-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36458/Lubby Holdings v Chung.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Reverses Damages Award For Sales Of Infringing Products Prior To Actual Notice Of Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 11340 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-post-grant-review-decision-finding-claims-indefinite 2021-09-14 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Post-Grant Review Decision Finding Claims Indefinite %26nbsp; 11346 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-09-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/36476/Team Worldwide Corp. v. Intex Recreation Corp., No. 20-1975 (Fed Cir. Sept. 9, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Post-Grant Review Decision Finding Claims Indefinite %26nbsp; file 13376 11346 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-delaware-determines-translator-device-limitations-are-subject-to 2021-09-20 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Delaware Determines %26ldquo;Translator Device%26rdquo; Limitations Are Subject To Means-Plus-Function Strictures And Invalidates Claims As Indefinite %26nbsp; 11352 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-09-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37549/DDE-1-20-cv-00662-141.pdf File: District Of Delaware Determines %26ldquo;Translator Device%26rdquo; Limitations Are Subject To Means-Plus-Function Strictures And Invalidates Claims As Indefinite %26nbsp; file 13376 11352 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-mandamus-request-seeking-to-require-service-under-hague-convention 2021-10-05 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Mandamus Request Seeking To Require Service Under Hague Convention %26nbsp; 11373 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-10-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37661/IN RE ONEPLUS TECHNOLOGY (SHENZHEN) CO., LTD.pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Mandamus Request Seeking To Require Service Under Hague Convention %26nbsp; file 13376 11373 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-arguments-that-the-uspto-is-unconstitutionally-structured 2021-10-18 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects Arguments That The USPTO Is Unconstitutionally Structured %26nbsp; 11384 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-10-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37778/Mobility Workx v. Unified Patents.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects Arguments That The USPTO Is Unconstitutionally Structured %26nbsp; file 13376 11384 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-exceptional-case-finding-and-award-of-attorney-fees 2021-10-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Exceptional Case Finding And Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees %26nbsp; 11391 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-10-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37812/IP_Energy Heating, LLC v. Heat On-The-Fly, Appeal No. 20-2038 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 14, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Exceptional Case Finding And Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees %26nbsp; file 13376 11391 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-orders-transfer-of-another-judge-albright-case 2021-11-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Orders Transfer Of Another Judge Albright Case %26nbsp; 11404 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-11-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37830/IP_21-182.ORDER.10-21-2021_1852720.pdf File: Federal Circuit Orders Transfer Of Another Judge Albright Case %26nbsp; file 13376 11404 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-ptab-finding-of-obviousness 2021-11-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Finding Of Obviousness %26nbsp; 11414 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-11-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37853/IP_20-2243.OPINION.11-4-2021_1859852.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB Finding Of Obviousness %26nbsp; file 13376 11414 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-dismissal-for-improper-venue-and-failure-to-state-a-claim 2021-11-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal For Improper Venue And Failure To State A Claim As To Domestic And Foreign Defendants Respectively %26nbsp; 11420 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-11-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37873/IP_21-12-05_Celgene Corp v. Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc._Venue.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal For Improper Venue And Failure To State A Claim As To Domestic And Foreign Defendants Respectively %26nbsp; file 13376 11420 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-texas-denies-motion-to-dismiss-patent-case-asserting-claims 2021-11-24 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of Texas Denies Motion To Dismiss Patent Case Asserting Claims Directed To Abstract Idea %26nbsp; 11450 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-11-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/37979/IP_Gravel Rating - EDTX-4-21-cv-00259-35_EDTX-4-21-cv-00329-31.pdf File: Eastern District Of Texas Denies Motion To Dismiss Patent Case Asserting Claims Directed To Abstract Idea %26nbsp; file 13376 11450 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-decides-ipr-petitioner-standing-in-two-appeals 2021-12-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Decides IPR Petitioner%26rsquo;s Standing In Two Appeals, With Different Outcomes %26nbsp; 11456 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-12-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38134/IPa_2021-12-01_ModernaTx, Inc. v. Arbuts Biopharma Corp._PATO_Obviousness.pdf File: Federal Circuit Decides IPR Petitioner%26rsquo;s Standing In Two Appeals, With Different Outcomes %26nbsp; file 13376 11456 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-12-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38135/IPb_ModernaTx v. Arbutus fka Protiva.pdf File: Federal Circuit Decides IPR Petitioner%26rsquo;s Standing In Two Appeals, With Different Outcomes %26nbsp; file 13376 11456 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-finding-that-patent-challenger-failed-to-show-claims 2021-12-20 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Finding That Patent Challenger Failed To Show Claims Relating To Accessing Web Content Outside Of A Browser Unpatentable %26nbsp; 11475 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-12-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38245/Lenovo Holding Co. v. DoDots Licensing Solutions, No. 21-1247 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 8, 2021).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Finding That Patent Challenger Failed To Show Claims Relating To Accessing Web Content Outside Of A Browser Unpatentable %26nbsp; file 13376 11475 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/judge-albright-of-the-western-district-of-texas-grants-motion-to-transfer 2021-12-20 0.5 13376 Blog Judge Albright Of The Western District Of Texas Grants Motion To Transfer On Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; 11476 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2021-12-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38246/WDTX-6-21-cv-00097-55.pdf File: Judge Albright Of The Western District Of Texas Grants Motion To Transfer On Convenience Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 11476 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-describes-written-description-requirement-for-negative-claim-limitations 2022-01-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Describes Written Description Requirement For Negative Claim Limitations %26nbsp; 11505 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-01-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38519/IP_21-1070.OPINION.1-3-2022_1887614 Novartis.pdf File: Federal Circuit Describes Written Description Requirement For Negative Claim Limitations %26nbsp; file 13376 11505 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-district-court-for-the-eastern-district-of-texas-denies-motion-to-stay 2022-01-18 0.5 13376 Blog The District Court For The Eastern District Of Texas Denies Motion To Stay Pending Ex Parte Reexamination %26nbsp; 11520 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-01-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38568/IP_Longhorn EDTX-2-20-cv-00349-72.pdf File: The District Court For The Eastern District Of Texas Denies Motion To Stay Pending Ex Parte Reexamination %26nbsp; file 13376 11520 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-mandamus-directing-transfer-from-eastern-district-of-texas 2022-01-24 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grants Mandamus Directing Transfer From Eastern District Of Texas To Northern District Of California %26nbsp; 11547 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-01-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38644/IP_In re Netflix.pdf File: Federal Circuit Grants Mandamus Directing Transfer From Eastern District Of Texas To Northern District Of California %26nbsp; file 13376 11547 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-court-indefiniteness-ruling-for-applying-incorrect-legal-standard 2022-01-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Indefiniteness Ruling For Applying Incorrect Legal Standard %26nbsp; 11568 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-01-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38775/IP_Nature Simulation Sys. Inc. v. Autodesk, Inc., No. 20-2257 (Jan. 27, 2022).pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Indefiniteness Ruling For Applying Incorrect Legal Standard %26nbsp; file 13376 11568 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-applicant-admitted-prior-art-cannot-be-the-basis 2022-02-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That Applicant Admitted Prior Art Cannot Be The Basis For An IPR Challenge %26nbsp; 11575 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-02-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38814/IP_2022-02-02_Qualcomm Inc. v. Apple Inc._PATO_Unpatentability.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That Applicant Admitted Prior Art Cannot Be The Basis For An IPR Challenge %26nbsp; file 13376 11575 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ipr-estoppel-under-35-usc-315-e-1-for-simultaneous-petitions 2022-02-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms IPR Estoppel Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(e)(1) For Simultaneous Petitions %26nbsp; 11592 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-02-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/38886/IP_2-11-2022 INTUITIVE SURGICAL, INC. v. ETHICON LLC 20-1481.OPINION.2-11-2022_1907139.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms IPR Estoppel Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(e)(1) For Simultaneous Petitions %26nbsp; file 13376 11592 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-a-price-quotation-can-trigger-an-on-sale-bar 2022-02-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That A Price %26ldquo;Quotation%26rdquo; Can Trigger An On-Sale Bar %26nbsp; 11681 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-02-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39008/IP_Junker v. Medical Components Inc. CAFC-21-1649-53.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That A Price %26ldquo;Quotation%26rdquo; Can Trigger An On-Sale Bar %26nbsp; file 13376 11681 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/us-district-court-for-the-eastern-district-of-texas-bifurcates-trial-over-counterclaims 2022-02-28 0.5 13376 Blog U.S. District Court For The Eastern District Of Texas Bifurcates Trial Over Counterclaims Asserting Patent Infringement Claims Directed To Distinct Technologies %26nbsp; 11705 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-02-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39086/IP_PNC Bank.pdf File: U.S. District Court For The Eastern District Of Texas Bifurcates Trial Over Counterclaims Asserting Patent Infringement Claims Directed To Distinct Technologies %26nbsp; file 13376 11705 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/western-district-of-texas-relies-on-relaxed-alter-ego-theory-to-deny-motion 2022-03-07 0.5 13376 Blog Western District Of Texas Relies On Relaxed Alter Ego Theory To Deny Motion To Dismiss For Improper Venue %26nbsp; 11711 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-03-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39112/IP_2022.02.11 WSOU v. Canon.pdf File: Western District Of Texas Relies On Relaxed Alter Ego Theory To Deny Motion To Dismiss For Improper Venue %26nbsp; file 13376 11711 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/western-district-of-texas-rejects-expert-hypothetical-negotiation-analysis 2022-03-14 0.5 13376 Blog Western District Of Texas Rejects Expert%26rsquo;s Hypothetical Negotiation Analysis That Used The Wrong Parties %26nbsp; 11723 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-03-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39151/IP_2022-03-03 Daedalus Blue v. SZ DJI Tech.pdf File: Western District Of Texas Rejects Expert%26rsquo;s Hypothetical Negotiation Analysis That Used The Wrong Parties %26nbsp; file 13376 11723 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-dismissal-of-complaint-asserting-ineligible-patent-claims 2022-03-22 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Complaint Asserting Ineligible Patent Claims %26nbsp; 11736 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-03-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39300/IP_Repifi Vendor Logistics, Inc. v. Intellicentrics, Inc., No. 21-1906 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 15, 2022).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Complaint Asserting Ineligible Patent Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 11736 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-exercises-discretion-to-deny-ipr-institution-due-to-itc-investigation 2022-04-04 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Exercises Discretion To Deny IPR Institution Due To ITC Investigation Despite Multiple Stayed District Court Cases %26nbsp; 11751 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-04-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39373/IP2_1475000-1475750-google di ipr2021-01578.pdf File: PTAB Exercises Discretion To Deny IPR Institution Due To ITC Investigation Despite Multiple Stayed District Court Cases %26nbsp; file 13376 11751 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-cites-limits-of-extrinsic-evidence-in-prosecution-disclaimer 2022-04-04 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Cites Limits Of Extrinsic Evidence In Prosecution Disclaimer %26nbsp; 11752 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-04-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39374/IP_Genuine v. Nintendo .pdf File: Federal Circuit Cites Limits Of Extrinsic Evidence In Prosecution Disclaimer %26nbsp; file 13376 11752 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rules-a-fastening-stem-need-not-fasten-separate-pieces 2022-04-18 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rules A %26ldquo;Fastening Stem%26rdquo; Need Not Fasten Separate Pieces %26nbsp; 11774 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-04-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39473/IP_Littelfuse Inc. v. Mersen USA EP Corp., case no. 21-2013 (CAFC).pdf File: Federal Circuit Rules A %26ldquo;Fastening Stem%26rdquo; Need Not Fasten Separate Pieces %26nbsp; file 13376 11774 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-again-finds-communications-attempting-to-resolve-a-patent-dispute 2022-04-26 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Again Finds Communications Attempting To Resolve A Patent Dispute Can Be A Basis For Personal Jurisdiction In Declaratory Judgment Action %26nbsp; 11784 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-04-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39493/IP1_2022-04-18_Apple Inc. v. Zipit Wireless, Inc_Infringement.pdf File: Federal Circuit Again Finds Communications Attempting To Resolve A Patent Dispute Can Be A Basis For Personal Jurisdiction In Declaratory Judgment Action %26nbsp; file 13376 11784 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/central-district-of-california-finds-a-presumption-of-patent-infringement-and-shifts 2022-04-26 0.5 13376 Blog Central District Of California Finds A Presumption Of Patent Infringement And Shifts The Burden To Defendants Pursuant To Section 295 %26nbsp; 11785 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-04-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39494/IP2_PureCircle CDCA-8-18-cv-01679-237.pdf File: Central District Of California Finds A Presumption Of Patent Infringement And Shifts The Burden To Defendants Pursuant To Section 295 %26nbsp; file 13376 11785 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-ptab-determination-that-claims-were-not-obvious 2022-05-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB Determination That Claims Were Not Obvious Because Of Flawed Motivation-To-Combine Analysis %26nbsp; 11829 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-05-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39657/IP0510_Auris Health, Inc. v. Intuitive Surgical Operations, __ F.4th __ (Fed. Cir. April 29, 2022).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB Determination That Claims Were Not Obvious Because Of Flawed Motivation-To-Combine Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 11829 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-finding-claims-unpatentable-based-on-a-patent 2022-05-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Claims Unpatentable Based On A Patent Application Publication%26rsquo;s Incorporation By Reference Of A Provisional Application %26nbsp; 11830 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-05-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39658/IP0517_22-1162.OPINION.5-6-2022_1947944.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Claims Unpatentable Based On A Patent Application Publication%26rsquo;s Incorporation By Reference Of A Provisional Application %26nbsp; file 13376 11830 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-asks-whether-prior-art-reference-is-by-another 2022-05-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Asks Whether Prior Art Reference Is %26ldquo;By Another%26rdquo; %26nbsp; 11855 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-05-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39728/IP_Google LLC v. IPA Technologies Inc., No. 2021-1179.pdf File: Federal Circuit Asks Whether Prior Art Reference Is %26ldquo;By Another%26rdquo; %26nbsp; file 13376 11855 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-orders-transfer-from-ed-texas-to-nd-california-where-accused-product 2022-06-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Orders Transfer From E.D. Texas To N.D. California Where Accused Product Was Developed %26nbsp; 11865 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-06-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39777/IP_In re Google CAFC 22-140.ORDER.5-23-2022.pdf File: Federal Circuit Orders Transfer From E.D. Texas To N.D. California Where Accused Product Was Developed %26nbsp; file 13376 11865 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-new-york-transfers-patent-case-for-improper-venue 2022-06-06 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of New York Transfers Patent Case For Improper Venue %26nbsp; 11877 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-06-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39832/IP_UI Techs. v. Ricoma, EDNY-2-22-cv-00220-37.pdf File: Eastern District Of New York Transfers Patent Case For Improper Venue %26nbsp; file 13376 11877 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-that-reliance-on-an-obvious-minor-clerical-error-is-not-a-defense 2022-06-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds That Reliance On An Obvious Minor Clerical Error Is Not A Defense To Willful Infringement %26nbsp; 11886 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-06-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39867/IP_21-1834.OPINION.6-3-2022_1960213.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds That Reliance On An Obvious Minor Clerical Error Is Not A Defense To Willful Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 11886 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-on-rehearing-vacates-prior-decision-holding-that-patent-claim 2022-07-05 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit On Rehearing Vacates Prior Decision Holding That Patent Claim With Negative Limitation Did Not Lack Written Description %26nbsp; 11923 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-07-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/39991/IP-625_21-1070.OPINION.6-21-2022_1967294.pdf File: Federal Circuit On Rehearing Vacates Prior Decision Holding That Patent Claim With Negative Limitation Did Not Lack Written Description %26nbsp; file 13376 11923 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-revisits-claim-construction-on-motion-for-summary-judgment-of-indefiniteness 2022-07-11 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Revisits Claim Construction On Motion For Summary Judgment Of Indefiniteness %26nbsp; 11936 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-07-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40060/IP_Chemours v Daikin DDE-1-17-cv-01612-392.pdf File: District Court Revisits Claim Construction On Motion For Summary Judgment Of Indefiniteness %26nbsp; file 13376 11936 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-attorneys-fees-for-frivolous-appeal 2022-07-19 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grants Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees For Frivolous Appeal %26nbsp; 11940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-07-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40147/IP_Pop Top Corp. v. Rakuten Kobo 21-2174.ORDER.7-14-2022_1977926.pdf File: Federal Circuit Grants Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees For Frivolous Appeal %26nbsp; file 13376 11940 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-decision-finding-organ-transplant-diagnosis-claims-unpatentable 2022-07-27 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Decision Finding Organ Transplant Diagnosis Claims Unpatentable %26nbsp; 11949 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-07-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40173/IP_CareDX, Inc. v. Natera, Inc. - CAFC-22-1027-55_CAFC-22-1028-7.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Decision Finding Organ Transplant Diagnosis Claims Unpatentable %26nbsp; file 13376 11949 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-award-of-attorneys-fees-for-patentees-forum-shopping 2022-08-03 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees For Patentee%26rsquo;s Forum-Shopping To Avoid An Adverse Section 101 Ruling %26nbsp; 11955 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-08-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40195/IP_2022-07-27_Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC v. Netflix, Inc._Ineligibility.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Award Of Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees For Patentee%26rsquo;s Forum-Shopping To Avoid An Adverse Section 101 Ruling %26nbsp; file 13376 11955 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-judicial-panel-on-multidistrict-litigation-consolidates-four-patent-cases 2022-08-15 0.5 13376 Blog The Judicial Panel On Multidistrict Litigation Consolidates Four Patent Cases In The Eastern District Of Texas %26nbsp; 11972 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-08-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40326/IP_TAASERA MDL Case.pdf File: The Judicial Panel On Multidistrict Litigation Consolidates Four Patent Cases In The Eastern District Of Texas %26nbsp; file 13376 11972 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-finding-of-unpatentability-of-patent-relating-to-ultrasonic 2022-08-22 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding Of Unpatentability Of Patent Relating To Ultrasonic Flow Meters And Housings, Involving Product-By-Process Claim Element %26nbsp; 11981 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-08-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40354/IP_Kamstrup v. Axioma Metering, Appeal No. 21-1923 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 12, 2022).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding Of Unpatentability Of Patent Relating To Ultrasonic Flow Meters And Housings, Involving Product-By-Process Claim Element %26nbsp; file 13376 11981 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-ipr-estoppel-applies-to-a-patent-claim-identified-in-an-ipr-petition 2022-09-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds IPR Estoppel Applies To A Patent Claim Identified In An IPR Petition But Not Considered In The Final Written Decision %26nbsp; 11990 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-09-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40397/IP2_Click-to-Call CAFC-22-1016-42.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds IPR Estoppel Applies To A Patent Claim Identified In An IPR Petition But Not Considered In The Final Written Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 11990 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-appellant-patentee-lacks-standing-in-an-appeal-from-an-inter-partes-review 2022-09-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Appellant Patentee Lacks Standing In An Appeal From An Inter Partes Review Finding Unpatentable A Claim Previously Cancelled In Ex Parte Reexamination %26nbsp; 11991 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-09-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40398/IP1_Best Medical v. Elekta - 21-2099.OPINION.8-29-2022_1996526.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Appellant Patentee Lacks Standing In An Appeal From An Inter Partes Review Finding Unpatentable A Claim Previously Cancelled In Ex Parte Reexamination %26nbsp; file 13376 11991 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-explores-capability-claims 2022-09-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Explores Capability Claims %26nbsp; 12013 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-09-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40498/IP_INVT v. ITC 20-1903.OPINION.8-31-2022_1997811.pdf File: Federal Circuit Explores Capability Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 12013 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-duplicative-litigation-doctrine 2022-09-29 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Duplicative-Litigation Doctrine %26nbsp; 12019 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-09-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40572/IP1_Arendi v LG - 21-1967.OPINION.9-7-2022_2000513.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Duplicative-Litigation Doctrine %26nbsp; file 13376 12019 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/eastern-district-of-texas-magistrate-recommends-denying-motion-to-dismiss-for-failure 2022-09-29 0.5 13376 Blog Eastern District Of Texas Magistrate Recommends Denying Motion To Dismiss For Failure To Perfect Service Of Process %26nbsp; 12020 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-09-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40573/IP2_Arigna.pdf File: Eastern District Of Texas Magistrate Recommends Denying Motion To Dismiss For Failure To Perfect Service Of Process %26nbsp; file 13376 12020 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-western-district-of-texas-denies-motion-to-transfer-based-on-improper-venue 2022-10-11 0.5 13376 Blog The Western District Of Texas Denies Motion To Transfer Based On Improper Venue As To Holding Company Defendant %26nbsp; 12029 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-10-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40600/IP2_Mov-Ology LLC v. Bigcommerce (W.D. Tex. Sept. 16, 2022).pdf File: The Western District Of Texas Denies Motion To Transfer Based On Improper Venue As To Holding Company Defendant %26nbsp; file 13376 12029 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-petition-for-writ-of-mandamus-on-venue-issues 2022-10-11 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Petition For Writ Of Mandamus On Venue Issues Based On Location Of Remote Employees%26rsquo; Homes %26nbsp; 12030 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-10-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40601/IP1_Monolithic.pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Petition For Writ Of Mandamus On Venue Issues Based On Location Of Remote Employees%26rsquo; Homes %26nbsp; file 13376 12030 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-director-issues-precedential-ptab-decision-finding-petitioners-conduct-an-abuse 2022-10-17 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Director Issues Precedential PTAB Decision Finding Petitioner%26rsquo;s Conduct An Abuse Of The Inter Partes Review Process %26nbsp; 12034 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-10-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40618/IP_Opensky Industries, LLC et al. v. VLSI Tech. LLC, IPR2021-01064, Paper No. 102 (P.T.A.B. Oct. 4, 2022).pdf File: USPTO Director Issues Precedential PTAB Decision Finding Petitioner%26rsquo;s Conduct An Abuse Of The Inter Partes Review Process %26nbsp; file 13376 12034 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-reiterates-that-computerizing-activities-traditionally-done-by-hand 2022-10-31 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Reiterates That Computerizing Activities Traditionally Done By Hand Usually Constitute Abstract Ideas Without An Inventive Concept, And Are Generally Not Patentable Subject Matter %26nbsp; 12061 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-10-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40701/IP1_2022-10-17_IBM v. Zillow Group, Inc._Infringement_Ineligibility.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Reiterates That Computerizing Activities Traditionally Done By Hand Usually Constitute Abstract Ideas Without An Inventive Concept, And Are Generally Not Patentable Subject Matter %26nbsp; file 13376 12061 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-eastern-district-of-texas-order-denying-transfer 2022-10-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Eastern District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Order Denying Transfer For Providing Insufficient Explanation %26nbsp; 12062 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-10-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40702/IP2_In re FedEx CAFC-22-156-13.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Eastern District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Order Denying Transfer For Providing Insufficient Explanation %26nbsp; file 13376 12062 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-use-of-a-restrictive-term-in-an-earlier-application-does-not-apply 2022-11-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds Use Of A Restrictive Term In An Earlier Application Does Not Apply In A Later Patent That Purposely Deletes The Restriction %26nbsp; 12065 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-11-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40716/IP_Finjan v ESET - CAFC Nov. 2022 - 21-2093-2022-11-01.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds Use Of A Restrictive Term In An Earlier Application Does Not Apply In A Later Patent That Purposely Deletes The Restriction %26nbsp; file 13376 12065 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-scheduling-order-pending-motion-to-transfer 2022-11-14 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Scheduling Order Pending Motion To Transfer %26nbsp; 12071 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-11-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40737/IP-In re Apple Inc. 22-162.ORDER.11-8-2022_2030260.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Scheduling Order Pending Motion To Transfer %26nbsp; file 13376 12071 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-allowing-ipr-claim-amendments-that-go-beyond 2022-11-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Allowing IPR Claim Amendments That Go Beyond Addressing Instituted Grounds %26nbsp; 12076 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-11-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40756/IP_American National v Sleep Number, Nov. 14 2022, CAFC-21-1382-6_CAFC-21-1323-7_CAFC-21-1379-6_CAFC-21-1321-88.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Allowing IPR Claim Amendments That Go Beyond Addressing Instituted Grounds %26nbsp; file 13376 12076 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-decision-striking-expert-report-and-granting-summary-judgment 2022-12-12 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Decision Striking Expert Report And Granting Summary Judgment Of Non-Infringement %26nbsp; 12094 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-12-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40823/IP2_Treehouse Avatar LLC v. Valve Corp., No. 21-1171 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 30, 2022).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Decision Striking Expert Report And Granting Summary Judgment Of Non-Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 12094 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-court-of-appeals-for-the-federal-circuit-finds-collateral-estoppel-applies-between-two-ipr 2022-12-12 0.5 13376 Blog The Court of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Finds Collateral Estoppel Applies Between Two IPR Proceedings And Invalidates Claims %26nbsp; 12099 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2022-12-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40826/IP1_21-2218.OPINION.12-8-2022_2045155.pdf File: The Court of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Finds Collateral Estoppel Applies Between Two IPR Proceedings And Invalidates Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 12099 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-addresses-claim-construction-invalidity-and-trade-dress-issues 2023-01-12 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Addresses Claim Construction, Invalidity, And Trade Dress Issues In Money-Clip Wallet Patent Case %26nbsp; 12108 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-01-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40909/IP_Mosaic Brands, Inc. v. Ridge Wallet LLC.pdf File: Federal Circuit Addresses Claim Construction, Invalidity, And Trade Dress Issues In Money-Clip Wallet Patent Case %26nbsp; file 13376 12108 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-lacks-jurisdiction-over-interlocutory-appeal-of-order-denying-in-house-counsel 2023-01-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Lacks Jurisdiction Over Interlocutory Appeal Of Order Denying In-House Counsel Access To Opposing Party%26rsquo;s Source Code %26nbsp; 12116 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-01-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/40942/IP_Modern Font Applications v Alaska Airlines 21-1838.OPINION.12-29-2022_2055096.pdf File: Federal Circuit Lacks Jurisdiction Over Interlocutory Appeal Of Order Denying In-House Counsel Access To Opposing Party%26rsquo;s Source Code %26nbsp; file 13376 12116 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-decision-finding-patent-invalid-under-section-101 2023-02-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Decision Finding Patent Invalid Under %26sect; 101 %26nbsp; 12134 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41014/IP1_Riggs v Cengage, Jan 17, 2023, CAFC-22-1468.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Decision Finding Patent Invalid Under %26sect; 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 12134 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-order-transferring-case-to-district-where-foreign-defendants 2023-02-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Order Transferring Case To District Where Foreign Defendants Had Consented To Personal Jurisdiction %26nbsp; 12135 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41015/IP2_In re Stingray IP Solutions, LLC, No. 2023-102 (Fed. Cir. 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Order Transferring Case To District Where Foreign Defendants Had Consented To Personal Jurisdiction %26nbsp; file 13376 12135 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-denies-application-of-ipr-time-limits 2023-02-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Denies Application of IPR Time Limits To Director Review %26nbsp; 12150 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41067/CyWee v. Google LLC 20-1565.OPINION.2-8-2023_2077658.pdf File: Federal Circuit Denies Application of IPR Time Limits To Director Review %26nbsp; file 13376 12150 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-court-congestion-factor-has-less-significance 2023-02-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That Court Congestion Factor Of The Transfer-For-Convenience Analysis Has Less Significance For Plaintiffs Not Engaged In Product Competition In The Marketplace %26nbsp; 12151 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41068/In re Google 23-101.ORDER.2-1-2023_2073596.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That Court Congestion Factor Of The Transfer-For-Convenience Analysis Has Less Significance For Plaintiffs Not Engaged In Product Competition In The Marketplace %26nbsp; file 13376 12151 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-preliminary-injunction-barring-patent-owner-from-notifying-customers 2023-02-27 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates Preliminary Injunction Barring Patent Owner From Notifying Customers Of Competitor%26rsquo;s Alleged Infringement %26nbsp; 12172 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41121/IP1_Lite-netics 1577000-1577661.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates Preliminary Injunction Barring Patent Owner From Notifying Customers Of Competitor%26rsquo;s Alleged Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 12172 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-director-affirms-rejection-of-invalidity-arguments-supported-only-by-expert-declaration 2023-02-27 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Director Affirms Rejection Of Invalidity Arguments Supported Only By Expert Declaration Parroting IPR Petition %26nbsp; 12173 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41122/IP2_2023-02-10 Xerox v Bytemark.pdf File: USPTO Director Affirms Rejection Of Invalidity Arguments Supported Only By Expert Declaration Parroting IPR Petition %26nbsp; file 13376 12173 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-disclosure-of-devices-at-major-industry-event-constituted-public-use 2023-02-27 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Disclosure Of Devices At Major Industry Event Constituted %26ldquo;Public Use%26rdquo; That Barred Patenting %26nbsp; 12174 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-02-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41124/IP3_2023-02-15_Minerva Surgical Inc. v. Hologic Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Disclosure Of Devices At Major Industry Event Constituted %26ldquo;Public Use%26rdquo; That Barred Patenting %26nbsp; file 13376 12174 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-revives-lawsuit-challenging-the-uspto-director-fintiv-instructions 2023-03-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Revives Lawsuit Challenging The USPTO Director%26rsquo;s Fintiv Instructions On A Limited Basis To Determine Whether They Were Improperly Issued Without A Notice-and-Comment Period %26nbsp; 12195 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-03-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41240/IP1_2023-03-13_Apple Inc. v. Vidal_PATO_Miscellaneous.pdf File: Federal Circuit Revives Lawsuit Challenging The USPTO Director%26rsquo;s Fintiv Instructions On A Limited Basis To Determine Whether They Were Improperly Issued Without A Notice-and-Comment Period %26nbsp; file 13376 12195 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-ptabs-finding-that-challenged-claim-was-not-unpatentable 2023-03-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That Challenged Claim Was Not Unpatentable Where PTAB Committed Legal Error By Requiring %26ldquo;Bodily Incorporation%26rdquo; Of Obviousness Combination %26nbsp; 12197 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-03-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41241/IP2_22-1038.OPINION.2-24-2023_2085786.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses PTAB%26rsquo;s Finding That Challenged Claim Was Not Unpatentable Where PTAB Committed Legal Error By Requiring %26ldquo;Bodily Incorporation%26rdquo; Of Obviousness Combination %26nbsp; file 13376 12197 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-united-states-district-court-for-the-southern-district-of-new-york-finds-that-patent-claims 2023-03-23 0.5 13376 Blog The United States District Court For The Southern District Of New York Finds That Patent Claims Directed To Picking An Outfit Are Not Patentable %26nbsp; 12198 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-claim-construction-of-indefinite-articles 2023-04-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Claim Construction Of Indefinite Articles %26nbsp; 12209 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-04-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41328/IP1_Salazar v AT%26T 21-2320.OPINION.4-5-2023_2105955.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Claim Construction Of Indefinite Articles %26nbsp; file 13376 12209 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/circuit-judge-allows-limited-path-forward-for-patent-plaintiff-after-its-experts-damages 2023-04-17 0.5 13376 Blog Circuit Judge Allows Limited Path Forward For Patent Plaintiff After Its Expert%26rsquo;s Damages Theories Are Excluded %26nbsp; 12210 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-04-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41329/IP2_2023-03-22 Acceleration Bay DDE-1-16-cv-00453-767.pdf File: Circuit Judge Allows Limited Path Forward For Patent Plaintiff After Its Expert%26rsquo;s Damages Theories Are Excluded %26nbsp; file 13376 12210 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-the-united-states-district-court-for-the-western-district-of-texas-claim 2023-05-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms The United States District Court For The Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Order And Entry Of Final Judgment Of Non-Infringement %26nbsp; 12253 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-05-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41560/IP1_Canopy Growth v. GW Pharma, Appeal No. 22.1603 (Fed. Cir April 24, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms The United States District Court For The Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Order And Entry Of Final Judgment Of Non-Infringement %26nbsp; file 13376 12253 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-final-written-decision-finding-fluorescence-detection-patent 2023-05-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Final Written Decision Finding Fluorescence Detection Patent Not Unpatentable as Obvious %26nbsp; 12254 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-05-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41561/IP2_Leica Microsystems, Inc. v. Regents of Univ. Mich., Appeal No. 22-1445 (Fed. Cir. April 24, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Final Written Decision Finding Fluorescence Detection Patent Not Unpatentable as Obvious %26nbsp; file 13376 12254 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-20m-patent-infringement-award 2023-05-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses $20M Patent Infringement Award %26nbsp; 12255 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-05-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41562/IP3_18-1049.OPINION.4-18-2023_2112573.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses $20M Patent Infringement Award %26nbsp; file 13376 12255 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-anticipation-based-on-misapplication-of-at-once-envisage-framework 2023-05-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects Anticipation Based On Misapplication Of %26ldquo;At Once Envisage%26rdquo; Framework %26nbsp; 12256 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-05-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41563/IP4_UCB v Actavis Labs. UT - CAFC-21-2336-20_CAFC-21-1924-65.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects Anticipation Based On Misapplication Of %26ldquo;At Once Envisage%26rdquo; Framework %26nbsp; file 13376 12256 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-unpatentability-of-gaming-machine-patent 2023-05-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Unpatentability Of Gaming Machine Patent %26nbsp; 12274 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-05-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41650/IP_Bot M8 LLC v. Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC, No. 22-1291 (Fed. Cir. 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Unpatentability Of Gaming Machine Patent %26nbsp; file 13376 12274 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-affirms-patentability-of-teleflex-patents-and-confirms-low-bar 2023-06-12 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Affirms Patentability Of Teleflex Patents And Confirms Low Bar For Corroboration Of Prior Inventorship %26nbsp; 12290 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-06-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41691/IP_5-24-2023 Medtronic v. Teleflex.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Affirms Patentability Of Teleflex Patents And Confirms Low Bar For Corroboration Of Prior Inventorship %26nbsp; file 13376 12290 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-finds-unified-patents-members-are-real-parties-in-interest-but-uspto-director 2023-06-20 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Finds Unified Patents%26rsquo; Members Are Real Parties In Interest, But USPTO Director Says Determination Was Unnecessary And Vacates %26nbsp; 12295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-06-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41701/IPa_Unified Patents PTAB-IPR2021-01413-79.pdf File: PTAB Finds Unified Patents%26rsquo; Members Are Real Parties In Interest, But USPTO Director Says Determination Was Unnecessary And Vacates %26nbsp; file 13376 12295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-06-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41702/IPb_Unified Patents PTAB-IPR2021-01413-76.pdf File: PTAB Finds Unified Patents%26rsquo; Members Are Real Parties In Interest, But USPTO Director Says Determination Was Unnecessary And Vacates %26nbsp; file 13376 12295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-citing-recent-scotus-opinion-on-enablement 2023-07-05 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB, Citing Recent SCOTUS Opinion On Enablement %26nbsp; 12303 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-07-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41795/IP1_Medytox v Galderma (Fed.Cir. June 27, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB, Citing Recent SCOTUS Opinion On Enablement %26nbsp; file 13376 12303 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-dismissal-for-failure-to-comply-with-discovery-order-and-under-kessler 2023-07-05 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal For Failure To Comply With Discovery Order And Under Kessler Doctrine %26nbsp; 12304 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-07-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41796/IP2_CAFC-22-2117-55 Askan v. Faro Technologies, Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal For Failure To Comply With Discovery Order And Under Kessler Doctrine %26nbsp; file 13376 12304 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-courts-preclusion-based-dismissal 2023-07-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Preclusion-Based Dismissal Of Induced Infringement Suit %26nbsp; 12317 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-07-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/41824/IP_Inguran, LLC v. ABS Global, Inc., No. 22-1385 (Fed. Cir. July 5, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court%26rsquo;s Preclusion-Based Dismissal Of Induced Infringement Suit %26nbsp; file 13376 12317 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-pure-aia-patents-are-not-subject-to-interferences 2023-07-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That Pure AIA Patents Are Not Subject To Interferences %26nbsp; 12338 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-07-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/42950/IP1_SNIPR Technologies Limited v Rockefeller University.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That Pure AIA Patents Are Not Subject To Interferences %26nbsp; file 13376 12338 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-ptab-final-written-decisions-because-the-board-erred 2023-07-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decisions Because The Board Erred In Its Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; 12339 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-07-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/42951/IP2_Axonics, Inc. v. Medtronic, Inc., (Fed. Cir. July 10, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decisions Because The Board Erred In Its Obviousness Analysis %26nbsp; file 13376 12339 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-tells-trinity-that-its-poll-based-network-patents-are-invalid 2023-08-07 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Tells Trinity That Its Poll-Based Network Patents Are Invalid %26nbsp; 12365 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-08-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/43013/IP1_7-14-2023 Trinity v. Covalent.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Tells Trinity That Its Poll-Based Network Patents Are Invalid %26nbsp; file 13376 12365 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-refuses-to-import-safety-and-efficacy-limitations-into-method-of-treatment 2023-08-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Refuses To Import Safety And Efficacy Limitations Into Method Of Treatment Claims And Affirms Induced Infringement Finding %26nbsp; 12366 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-08-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/43014/IP2_UNITED THERAPEUTICS CORPORATION v. LIQUIDIA TECHNOLOGIES, INC. - 22-2217.OPINION.7-24-2023_2161663.pdf File: Federal Circuit Refuses To Import Safety And Efficacy Limitations Into Method Of Treatment Claims And Affirms Induced Infringement Finding %26nbsp; file 13376 12366 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/seventh-circuit-clarifies-forum-selection-clause-applies-only-to-contracting-parties 2023-08-15 0.5 13376 Blog Seventh Circuit Clarifies Forum Selection Clause Applies Only To Contracting Parties %26nbsp; 12378 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-08-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/43060/IP_Nulogy_Corporation_v._Menasha.pdf File: Seventh Circuit Clarifies Forum Selection Clause Applies Only To Contracting Parties %26nbsp; file 13376 12378 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-western-district-of-texas-order-granting-summary-judgment-to-defendant 2023-09-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Order Granting Summary Judgment To Defendant Under %26sect; 101 %26nbsp; 12394 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-09-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44689/IP_USC IP Partnership v. Meta Platforms, Inc. (Fed. Cir. Aug. 30, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Order Granting Summary Judgment To Defendant Under %26sect; 101 %26nbsp; file 13376 12394 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-on-motivation-to-combine-and-reasonable-expectation 2023-10-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB On Motivation To Combine And Reasonable Expectation Of Success %26nbsp; 13416 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44819/IP1_Elekta v Zap, Fed.Cir. 2021-1985, decided Sept 21, 2023.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB On Motivation To Combine And Reasonable Expectation Of Success %26nbsp; file 13376 13416 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-antibody-claims-invalid-for-lack-of-enablement 2023-10-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Antibody Claims Invalid For Lack Of Enablement In View Of Amgen %26nbsp; 13417 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44820/IP2_Baxalta Inc v. Genentech Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Antibody Claims Invalid For Lack Of Enablement In View Of Amgen %26nbsp; file 13376 13417 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-tells-ptab-to-base-its-decision-on-grounds-the-parties-raise 2023-10-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Tells PTAB To Base Its Decision On Grounds The Parties Raise %26nbsp; 13418 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44821/IP3_9-11-2023 Apple v. Corephotonics.pdf File: Federal Circuit Tells PTAB To Base Its Decision On Grounds The Parties Raise %26nbsp; file 13376 13418 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-claim-construction-interpretation-and-upholds-refusal-to-allow 2023-10-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Claim Construction Interpretation And Upholds Refusal To Allow Impermissibly Broad Substitute Claims %26nbsp; 13419 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44822/IP4_Sisvel International SA v Sierra Wireless Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Claim Construction Interpretation And Upholds Refusal To Allow Impermissibly Broad Substitute Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 13419 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-unpatentability-finding-of-medical-alarm-patent 2023-10-09 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Unpatentability Finding Of Medical Alarm Patent %26nbsp; 13420 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-09 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44823/IP5_22-1415.OPINION.9-28-2023_2197756.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Unpatentability Finding Of Medical Alarm Patent %26nbsp; file 13376 13420 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-reminds-the-ptab-of-the-meaning-of-a 2023-10-31 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Reminds The PTAB Of The Meaning Of %26ldquo;A%26rdquo; %26nbsp; 13443 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44913/IP1_ABS Global v. Cytonome.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Reminds The PTAB Of The Meaning Of %26ldquo;A%26rdquo; %26nbsp; file 13376 13443 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-district-court-ruling-as-to-nonobviousness-and-damages 2023-10-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses District Court Ruling As To Nonobviousness And Damages %26nbsp; 13444 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44914/IP2_Cyntec Company Ltd v Chilisin Electronics Corp.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses District Court Ruling As To Nonobviousness And Damages %26nbsp; file 13376 13444 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-western-district-of-texas-final-judgment-of-invalidity 2023-10-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Final Judgment Of Invalidity %26nbsp; 13445 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-10-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44915/IP3_WSOU Investments LLC v. Google LLC (Fed. Cir. Oct. 6, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Western District Of Texas%26rsquo;s Final Judgment Of Invalidity %26nbsp; file 13376 13445 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-ptab-sufficiently-addressed-arguments-actually-raised-in-ipr-petitions 2023-11-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds PTAB Sufficiently Addressed Arguments Actually Raised In IPR Petitions %26nbsp; 13456 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-11-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44944/IP_Netflix v DivX 22-1203.OPINION.10-25-2023_2211191.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds PTAB Sufficiently Addressed Arguments Actually Raised In IPR Petitions %26nbsp; file 13376 13456 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-attorneys-fees-award-against-patentee-personalweb 2023-11-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Award Against Patentee PersonalWeb %26nbsp; 13460 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-11-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44979/IP_In Re Personalweb Tech, Fed. Cir. 2021-1858,1859,1860.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Award Against Patentee PersonalWeb %26nbsp; file 13376 13460 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-finding-semiconductor-patent-unpatentable 2023-11-20 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision Finding Semiconductor Patent Unpatentable After Addressing Threshold Question Relating To Original Assignee%26rsquo;s Interest In Patent %26nbsp; 13467 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-11-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44997/IPa_Bell Semiconductor LLC v. Advanced Semiconductor Engineering, Inc., 22-2048, No. 35 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 24, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision Finding Semiconductor Patent Unpatentable After Addressing Threshold Question Relating To Original Assignee%26rsquo;s Interest In Patent %26nbsp; file 13376 13467 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-11-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/44998/IPb_Bell Semiconductor v. Advanced Semiconductor Engineering, Appeal No. 22-2048 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 17, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Decision Finding Semiconductor Patent Unpatentable After Addressing Threshold Question Relating To Original Assignee%26rsquo;s Interest In Patent %26nbsp; file 13376 13467 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-final-written-decision-holding-that-the-passing 2023-12-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decision, Holding That The Passing Of The Statutory Deadline Did Not Deprive The Board Of Authority To Issue Its Decision %26nbsp; 13491 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-12-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45222/IP_Purdue Pharma v. Collegium (Fed. Cir. Nov. 21, 2023).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decision, Holding That The Passing Of The Statutory Deadline Did Not Deprive The Board Of Authority To Issue Its Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 13491 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rules-that-defendants-abbreviated 2023-12-18 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rules That Defendants%26rsquo; Abbreviated New Drug Applications Did Not Infringe Plaintiffs%26rsquo; Drug Patents 13495 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2023-12-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45239/Lundbeck v Lupin Ltd.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rules That Defendants%26rsquo; Abbreviated New Drug Applications Did Not Infringe Plaintiffs%26rsquo; Drug Patents file 13376 13495 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-district-courts 2024-01-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds District Court%26rsquo;s Construction Of %26ldquo;Barcode%26rdquo; Too Narrow %26nbsp; 13524 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-01-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45382/5_K-Fee System GMBH v Nespresso USA - 22-2042.OPINION.12-26-2023_2244064.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds District Court%26rsquo;s Construction Of %26ldquo;Barcode%26rdquo; Too Narrow %26nbsp; file 13376 13524 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-nullifies-22-billion-judgment 2024-01-08 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Nullifies $2.2 Billion Judgment %26nbsp; 13525 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-01-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45383/6_VLSI v. Intel Corp (Fed. Cir. 12.04.23).pdf File: The Federal Circuit Nullifies $2.2 Billion Judgment %26nbsp; file 13376 13525 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-finding-cha 2024-01-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Challenged Claims Unpatentable and Denying Motion to Amend the Claims %26nbsp; 13555 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-01-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45451/Cywee Group LTD v. ZTE (USA), Inc., Appeal No. 21-1855 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 18, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Challenged Claims Unpatentable and Denying Motion to Amend the Claims %26nbsp; file 13376 13555 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/patent-claims-that-do-nothing-more-than-impr 2024-01-23 0.5 13376 Blog Patent Claims That %26ldquo;Do Nothing More Than Improve A User%26rsquo;s Experience%26rdquo; Are Abstract %26nbsp; 13556 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-01-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45452/IBM v Zillow, Jan 9, 2024, CAFC-22-1861.pdf File: Patent Claims That %26ldquo;Do Nothing More Than Improve A User%26rsquo;s Experience%26rdquo; Are Abstract %26nbsp; file 13376 13556 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabs-final-written-decision 2024-01-30 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decision, Holding That Obviousness Does Not Require An Actual, Physical Substitution Of Elements 13565 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-01-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45474/04_Omega Patents v. BMW (Fed. Cir. Jan. 22, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Final Written Decision, Holding That Obviousness Does Not Require An Actual, Physical Substitution Of Elements file 13376 13565 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-ptab-implicitly-and-incorrectly 2024-02-12 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds PTAB Implicitly And Incorrectly Construed Claim In Final Decision %26nbsp; 13584 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-02-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45624/11_22-1750.OPINION.2-7-2024_2266326 Google v Ecofactor.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds PTAB Implicitly And Incorrectly Construed Claim In Final Decision %26nbsp; file 13376 13584 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-findings-of-the-international 2024-02-12 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Findings Of The International Trade Commission With Respect To Media Device Patent %26nbsp; 13585 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-02-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45625/12_Roku, Inc. v. ITC (Appellee) Universal Electronics Inc. (Intervenor) 22-1386.OPINION.1-19-2024_2255688.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Findings Of The International Trade Commission With Respect To Media Device Patent %26nbsp; file 13376 13585 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/product-operating-manuals-distributed-to-customers 2024-02-20 0.5 13376 Blog Product Operating Manuals Distributed To Customers Are %26ldquo;Printed Publications,%26rdquo; Notwithstanding Confidentiality Provisions And Limited Dissemination %26nbsp; 13588 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-02-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45664/Weber v Provisur, Feb 8, 2024, Fed. Cir. 2022-1751,1813.pdf File: Product Operating Manuals Distributed To Customers Are %26ldquo;Printed Publications,%26rdquo; Notwithstanding Confidentiality Provisions And Limited Dissemination %26nbsp; file 13376 13588 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-on-correct 2024-03-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court On Correction Of Inventorship 13619 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-03-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45819/Tube-Mac v Campbell, CAFC-22-2170.OPINION.3-15-2024_2286179.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court On Correction Of Inventorship file 13376 13619 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-ptab-decision 2024-03-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB Decision Regarding Patents For Adult Incontinence Diapers 13620 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-03-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45813/17_Hartmann v. Attends 22-1724.OPINION.3-4-2024.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB Decision Regarding Patents For Adult Incontinence Diapers file 13376 13620 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-district-court-erred 2024-03-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds District Court Erred in Concluding Claim Limitations Contradictory 13621 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-03-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45814/16_Maxell v Amperex 23-1194.OPINION.3-6-2024_2281183.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds District Court Erred in Concluding Claim Limitations Contradictory file 13376 13621 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-underscores-importance-of-careful 2024-03-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Underscores Importance Of Carefully Reviewing The Language In A Covenant Not To Sue When Entering A License Agreement 13622 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-03-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45815/18_AlexSam v. MasterCard (Fed. Cir. Feb. 28, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Underscores Importance Of Carefully Reviewing The Language In A Covenant Not To Sue When Entering A License Agreement file 13376 13622 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-finding 2024-03-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Unpatentable Challenged Claims Of Medical-Imaging Patent 13623 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-03-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45816/19_D3D Technologies, Inc. v. Microsoft Corp., Appeal No. 23-1075 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 20, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Finding Unpatentable Challenged Claims Of Medical-Imaging Patent file 13376 13623 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-challenged-claims-of-laser 2024-04-01 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Challenged Claims of Laser Projector Alignment Patent Not Unpatentable 13642 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-04-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45935/Virtek Vision Int'l v. Assembly Guidance Systems, Appeal No. 22-1998 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 37, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Challenged Claims of Laser Projector Alignment Patent Not Unpatentable file 13376 13642 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-district-court-of-delaware 2024-04-08 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Of Delaware%26rsquo;s Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal Holding Asserted Claims Unpatentable Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 101. 13655 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-04-08 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/45974/06_AI Visualize v. Nuance Communications (Fed. Cir. April 4, 2024).pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court Of Delaware%26rsquo;s Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissal Holding Asserted Claims Unpatentable Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 101. file 13376 13655 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-is-amenable-under-certain 2024-04-22 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Is Amenable, Under Certain Circumstances, To Allowing A Patent Owner To Seek Foreign Damages For Domestic Infringement 13672 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-04-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46032/Brumfield v. IBG LLC.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Is Amenable, Under Certain Circumstances, To Allowing A Patent Owner To Seek Foreign Damages For Domestic Infringement file 13376 13672 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-standard-for-the-injury 2024-05-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Standard For The Injury In Fact Requirement For Standing 13694 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-05-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46263/06_Intellectual Tech LLC v. Zebra Technologies Corp. - 22-2207.OPINION.5-1-2024_2310958.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Standard For The Injury In Fact Requirement For Standing file 13376 13694 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/fourth-circuit-affirms-decision-denying-timberland 2024-05-07 0.5 13376 Blog Fourth Circuit Affirms Decision Denying Timberland Trade Dress Registration For Its Signature Boot 13695 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-05-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46264/07_4th Cir - TBL Licensing LLC v Vidal.pdf File: Fourth Circuit Affirms Decision Denying Timberland Trade Dress Registration For Its Signature Boot file 13376 13695 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-district-courts 2024-05-13 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates District Court%26rsquo;s Judgment Of Patent Infringement Following Affirmance Of Invalidity At The PTAB 13707 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-05-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46308/Packet Intelligence v Netscout - 22-2064.OPINION.5-2-2024_2311705.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates District Court%26rsquo;s Judgment Of Patent Infringement Following Affirmance Of Invalidity At The PTAB file 13376 13707 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/ptab-denies-institution-of-supplierrsquos-ipr 2024-05-21 0.5 13376 Blog PTAB Denies Institution Of Supplier%26rsquo;s IPR Petition Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(b) 13716 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-05-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46335/04_IPR2024-00101 No. 10 Institution Decision Deny - Institution Decision Deny (P.T.A.B. May. 9 2024).pdf File: PTAB Denies Institution Of Supplier%26rsquo;s IPR Petition Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 315(b) file 13376 13716 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-attorneys-fees-under-35 2024-05-28 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 285 Do Not Include Parallel IPR Fees And Denies Recovery From Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Counsel 13730 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-05-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46409/04_Dragon Intellectual Property, LLC v. DISH Network L.L.C.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds Attorneys%26rsquo; Fees Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 285 Do Not Include Parallel IPR Fees And Denies Recovery From Plaintiff%26rsquo;s Counsel file 13376 13730 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-creates-a-new-standard 2024-06-03 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Creates A New Standard For Assessing The Nonobviousness Of Design Patents 13739 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-06-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46448/5-30-2024 LKQ v. GM Global Opinion.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Creates A New Standard For Assessing The Nonobviousness Of Design Patents file 13376 13739 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/new-jersey-district-court-orders-delisting 2024-06-17 0.5 13376 Blog New Jersey District Court Orders Delisting Of Teva Inhaler Patents From The Orange Book 13757 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-06-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46548/Teva v. Amneal, No. 23-cv-20964 (SRC) __ F. Supp. 3d __ (D.N.J. June 10, 2024).pdf File: New Jersey District Court Orders Delisting Of Teva Inhaler Patents From The Orange Book file 13376 13757 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-06-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46551/Teva v. Amneal, Order Granting in Part Motion to Stay (D.N.J. June 13, 2024).pdf File: New Jersey District Court Orders Delisting Of Teva Inhaler Patents From The Orange Book file 13376 13757 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-grant-of-preliminary 2024-06-24 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Grant Of Preliminary Injunction Enjoining Use Of Alleged Trade Secrets As Abuse Of Discretion 13766 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-06-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/46561/INSULET CORP. v. EOFLOW - 24-1137.OPINION.6-17-2024_2334858.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Grant Of Preliminary Injunction Enjoining Use Of Alleged Trade Secrets As Abuse Of Discretion file 13376 13766 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/dismissal-of-beteiro-suit-against-six-gambling-services-companies 2024-07-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Beteiro LLC%26rsquo;s Suit Against Six Gambling Services Companies Because Patents Claimed Nonpatentable Subject Matter 13826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47642/22-2275.OPINION.6-21-2024_2337276.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Dismissal Of Beteiro LLC%26rsquo;s Suit Against Six Gambling Services Companies Because Patents Claimed Nonpatentable Subject Matter file 13376 13826 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/national-cross-border-infringement-actions-ready-for-a-serious-comeback 2024-07-17 0.5 13376 Blog National Cross-Border Infringement Actions:%26nbsp; Ready For A Serious Comeback? 13827 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47643/Electrolux - BSH - Conclusie AG C-339-22 22 february 2024.pdf File: National Cross-Border Infringement Actions:%26nbsp; Ready For A Serious Comeback? file 13376 13827 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/director-vidal-reverses-ptab-denial-of-institution-of-iprs-for-toy-gun-patents 2024-07-17 0.5 13376 Blog Director Vidal Grants Director Review And Reverses PTAB%26rsquo;s Denial Of Institution Of IPRs For Toy Gun Patents 13828 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47644/1856000-1856811-july 9 spin master (1).pdf File: Director Vidal Grants Director Review And Reverses PTAB%26rsquo;s Denial Of Institution Of IPRs For Toy Gun Patents file 13376 13828 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-dismissal-of-induced-infringement-claim-based-on-skinny-label 2024-07-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Dismissal Of Induced Infringement Claim Based On Skinny Label And Marketing Materials 13829 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47645/Amarin Pharma, Inc. v. Hikma Pharmaceuticals USA Inc. - 23-1169.OPINION.6-25-2024_2339226.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Dismissal Of Induced Infringement Claim Based On Skinny Label And Marketing Materials file 13376 13829 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-updates-guidance-on-patent-subject-matter 2024-07-22 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Updates Guidance On Patent Subject Matter Eligibility For AI And Other Emerging Technologies 13852 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47656/USPTO 2024-07 ai examples.pdf File: USPTO Updates Guidance On Patent Subject Matter Eligibility For AI And Other Emerging Technologies file 13376 13852 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-upholds-preliminary-injunction 2024-07-29 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Upholds Preliminary Injunction Barring Sale Of Cancer Test 13874 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-07-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47689/24-1324.OPINION.7-12-2024_2349134 (1).pdf File: Federal Circuit Upholds Preliminary Injunction Barring Sale Of Cancer Test file 13376 13874 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-provides-guidance-on-estoppel-provision 2024-08-05 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On Estoppel Provision Under 37 C.F.R. %26sect; 42.73(d)(3)(i)%26nbsp; 13899 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-08-05 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47760/23-1005.OPINION.7-26-2024_2357128.pdf File: Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On Estoppel Provision Under 37 C.F.R. %26sect; 42.73(d)(3)(i)%26nbsp; file 13376 13899 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-provides-guidance-on-35-usc 2024-08-12 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 102(b)(2)(B)%26rsquo;s Public Disclosure Exception To Prior Art 13909 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-08-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47783/23-1336.OPINION.7-31-2024_2359524.pdf File: Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 102(b)(2)(B)%26rsquo;s Public Disclosure Exception To Prior Art file 13376 13909 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-america-invents-act-do 2024-08-19 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That America Invents Act Does Not Affect On-Sale Bar To Patentability%26nbsp; 13919 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-08-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47795/22-1827.OPINION.8-12-2024_2365402.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That America Invents Act Does Not Affect On-Sale Bar To Patentability%26nbsp; file 13376 13919 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/standing-amp-product-development-platinum 2024-08-26 0.5 13376 Blog Standing %26amp; Product Development:%26nbsp;Platinum Optics Tech. Inc. v. Viavi Sols. Inc. 13926 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-08-26 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47816/23-1227.OPINION.8-16-2024_2368511 Platinum Optics.pdf File: Standing %26amp; Product Development:%26nbsp;Platinum Optics Tech. Inc. v. Viavi Sols. Inc. file 13376 13926 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-sect-101-summary-judgment 2024-09-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses %26sect; 101 Summary Judgment Of Invalidity, Holding That Describing Claims At High Level Of Abstraction And Untethered From The Claims%26rsquo; Language All But Ensures That The Exceptions To %26sect; 101 Swallow The Rule 13955 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47877/Contour IP v. GoPro.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses %26sect; 101 Summary Judgment Of Invalidity, Holding That Describing Claims At High Level Of Abstraction And Untethered From The Claims%26rsquo; Language All But Ensures That The Exceptions To %26sect; 101 Swallow The Rule file 13376 13955 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-newly-proposed-restore-patent-bill 2024-09-17 0.5 13376 Blog The Newly Proposed RESTORE Patent Bill Aims To Give Patent Owners More Power 13956 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47868/The RESTORE Bill.pdf File: The Newly Proposed RESTORE Patent Bill Aims To Give Patent Owners More Power file 13376 13956 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-provides-clarity-on-proper-obviou 2024-09-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Provides Clarity On Proper Obviousness-Type Double Patenting References 13957 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47869/Allergan-v-MSN-24-1061.OPINION.8-13-2024_2366074.pdf File: Federal Circuit Provides Clarity On Proper Obviousness-Type Double Patenting References file 13376 13957 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/standing-and-product-development 2024-09-17 0.5 13376 Blog Standing And Product Development:%26nbsp; Platinum Optics Tech. Inc. v. Viavi Sols. Inc 13958 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47871/23-1227.OPINION.8-16-2024_2368511 Platinum Optics1.pdf File: Standing And Product Development:%26nbsp; Platinum Optics Tech. Inc. v. Viavi Sols. Inc file 13376 13958 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-that-the-meaning 2024-09-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies That The Meaning Of A Claim Term Can Vary While Still Remaining Consistent 13982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/47969/[IP] Teleflex v. Medtronic.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies That The Meaning Of A Claim Term Can Vary While Still Remaining Consistent file 13376 13982 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-upholds-invalidation-of-photo-tag 2024-09-30 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Upholds Invalidation Of Photo-Tagging Patents Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 101 And Alice/Mayo %26nbsp; 13987 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-09-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48009/[IP] 22-2100.OPINION.9-17-2024_2385681.pdf File: Federal Circuit Upholds Invalidation Of Photo-Tagging Patents Under 35 U.S.C. %26sect; 101 And Alice/Mayo %26nbsp; file 13376 13987 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-infringement-and-willfulness 2024-10-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Infringement And Willfulness Determinations And Finds Damages Verdict Improperly Relies On Entire Market Value Rule%26nbsp; 14005 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-10-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48057/[IP] PROVISUR TECHNOLOGIES, INC. v. WEBER, INC.pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Infringement And Willfulness Determinations And Finds Damages Verdict Improperly Relies On Entire Market Value Rule%26nbsp; file 13376 14005 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-denies-regenerons-motion-for-preliminary 2024-10-21 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Denies Regeneron%26rsquo;s Motion For Preliminary Injunction To Block Amgen%26rsquo;s Eylea Biosimilar 14038 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-10-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48100/[IP 1] In Re_ Aflibercept Patent Litigation, Docket No. 1_24-md-03103 (N.D. W. Va. Apr 11, 2024), Court Docket.pdf File: District Court Denies Regeneron%26rsquo;s Motion For Preliminary Injunction To Block Amgen%26rsquo;s Eylea Biosimilar file 13376 14038 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/trial-court-determination-that-a-complaint 2024-10-21 0.5 13376 Blog Trial Court Determination That A Complaint Allegation Is Conclusory Is Subject To De Novo Review 14039 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-10-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48101/[IP 2] Alexsam v Aetna 22-2036.OPINION.10-8-2024_2398426.pdf File: Trial Court Determination That A Complaint Allegation Is Conclusory Is Subject To De Novo Review file 13376 14039 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-keeps-open-possibility-of-antisuit 2024-10-28 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Keeps Open Possibility Of Antisuit Injunction In Ericsson v. Lenovo 14059 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-10-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48123/[IP] 24-1515.OPINION.10-24-2024_2408080.pdf File: Federal Circuit Keeps Open Possibility Of Antisuit Injunction In Ericsson v. Lenovo file 13376 14059 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-unpatentability-find 2024-11-04 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Unpatentability Findings Regarding Network Security Patents 14077 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-11-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48136/[IP] 23-1654.OPINION.10-31-2024_2412048.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Unpatentability Findings Regarding Network Security Patents file 13376 14077 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/election-results-are-in-heres-how-ip-disputes-policy-may-change 2024-11-11 0.5 13376 Blog Election Results Are In%26mdash;Here%26rsquo;s How IP Disputes Policy May Change 14101 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-reinforces-high-bar-for-applying 2024-11-18 0.5 13376 Blog District Court Reinforces High Bar For Applying Patent Prosecution Bar 14125 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-11-18 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48182/IP.pdf File: District Court Reinforces High Bar For Applying Patent Prosecution Bar file 13376 14125 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-provides-guidance-on-rule-12-b-6-stage-claim-construction 2024-11-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On Rule 12(b)(6) Stage Claim Construction 14144 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-11-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48196/(1) 23-1435.OPINION.10-18-2024_2404584.pdf File: Federal Circuit Provides Guidance On Rule 12(b)(6) Stage Claim Construction file 13376 14144 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-of-massachusetts-invalidates-epigenetics 2024-12-10 0.5 13376 Blog District Of Massachusetts Invalidates Epigenetics Method Patents For Lack Of Eligible Subject Matter 14196 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-12-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48234/[IP 1] bimodal v. NEB PI and MTD Opinion.pdf File: District Of Massachusetts Invalidates Epigenetics Method Patents For Lack Of Eligible Subject Matter file 13376 14196 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-non-infringement-judgement-on-document-stream-patents 2024-12-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Non-Infringement At Summary Judgment On %26ldquo;Document Stream%26rdquo; Patents In Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. 14197 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-12-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48235/[IP 2] 22-1600.OPINION.12-4-2024_2429866.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Non-Infringement At Summary Judgment On %26ldquo;Document Stream%26rdquo; Patents In Mirror Worlds Technologies, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc. file 13376 14197 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-and-remands-ptab-decision-in-palo-alto-networks-v-centripetal-networks 2024-12-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB Decision In Palo Alto Networks v. Centripetal Networks Over Motivation To Combine Prior Art 14242 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2024-12-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48267/Palo Alto Networks v. Centripetal Networks.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates And Remands PTAB Decision In Palo Alto Networks v. Centripetal Networks Over Motivation To Combine Prior Art file 13376 14242 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/alleged-inappropriate-conduct-in-another-litigati 2025-01-21 0.5 13376 Blog Alleged Inappropriate Conduct In Another Litigation Does Not Support Award Of Enhanced Damages 14291 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-01-13 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/48307/[IP] 10x Genomics Inc. v. Bruker Spatial Biology Inc.pdf File: Alleged Inappropriate Conduct In Another Litigation Does Not Support Award Of Enhanced Damages file 13376 14291 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-regarding-d 2025-01-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Regarding DNA Sampling Patent 16295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-01-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50329/Lab’y Corp. of America Holdings v. Ravgen, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision Regarding DNA Sampling Patent file 13376 16295 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-published-patent-applications-are-prior-art-in-iprs 2025-01-30 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms That Published Patent Applications Are Prior Art in IPRs As Of Their Filing Dates, Not Their Publication Dates 16328 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-01-30 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50364/[IP] Lynk Labs Inc. v. Samsung.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms That Published Patent Applications Are Prior Art in IPRs As Of Their Filing Dates, Not Their Publication Dates file 13376 16328 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-holds-that-ptab-has-jurisdiction- 2025-02-04 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Holds That PTAB Has Jurisdiction To Review Expired Patents 16332 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-02-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50377/[IP] Apple Inc. v. Gesture Tech. Partners.pdf File: Federal Circuit Holds That PTAB Has Jurisdiction To Review Expired Patents file 13376 16332 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grants-preliminary-injunction-against-biosimilar-applicants 2025-02-10 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Finding Of Personal Jurisdiction And Preliminary Injunction Against Biosimilar Applicants 16358 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-02-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50427/[IP] Regeneron Pharms., Inc. v. Mylan Pharms. Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Finding Of Personal Jurisdiction And Preliminary Injunction Against Biosimilar Applicants file 13376 16358 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-limits-scope-of-damages-awards-in-trademark-infringement-action 2025-03-10 0.5 13376 Blog Supreme Court Limits Scope Of Damages Awards In A Trademark Infringement Action 16462 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-03-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50523/[IP 1] Dewberry Grp., Inc. v. Dewberry Eng'rs Inc.pdf File: Supreme Court Limits Scope Of Damages Awards In A Trademark Infringement Action file 13376 16462 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/poster-presentation-tied-to-business-objectives-evidence-of-infringement-of-patented-methods 2025-03-10 0.5 13376 Blog Poster Presentation Tied To Business Objectives Serves As Evidence Of Infringement Of Patented Methods 16465 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-03-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50526/[IP 2] 10X Genomics, Inc. v. Parse Biosciences, Inc.pdf File: Poster Presentation Tied To Business Objectives Serves As Evidence Of Infringement Of Patented Methods file 13376 16465 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-expands-economic-prong-of-section-337 2025-03-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Expands Economic Prong Of Section 337 Domestic Industry Requirement 16487 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-03-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50549/[IP] Lashify, Inc. v. Int'l Trade Comm'n.pdf File: Federal Circuit Expands Economic Prong Of Section 337 Domestic Industry Requirement file 13376 16487 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/requirements-for-a-prior-art-reference-entitlement-to-filing-date 2025-03-31 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Requirements For A Prior Art Reference%26rsquo;s Entitlement To The Filing Date Of A Provisional Application To Which It Claims Priority 16524 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-03-31 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50595/[IP] In re Riggs.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Requirements For A Prior Art Reference%26rsquo;s Entitlement To The Filing Date Of A Provisional Application To Which It Claims Priority file 13376 16524 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-requirements-to-establish-convoyed-sales-in-patent-damages 2025-04-07 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Requirements To Establish Convoyed Sales In Patent Damages 16553 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-04-07 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50632/[IP] Wash World Inc. v. Belanger Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Requirements To Establish Convoyed Sales In Patent Damages file 13376 16553 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-decision-on-unpatentability 2025-04-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision On Unpatentability, With The PTO Stepping In After Appellee Withdrew 16610 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-04-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50719/[IP 1] Sage Prods. v. Coke Morgan Stewart.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB Decision On Unpatentability, With The PTO Stepping In After Appellee Withdrew file 13376 16610 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/infringement-of-patent-claiming-dosing-regimen-for-long-acting-antipsychotic-injectable 2025-04-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Findings Of Non-Obviousness And Infringement Of Method Of Treatment Patent Claiming Dosing Regimen For Long-Acting Antipsychotic Injectable 16612 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-04-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50720/[IP 2] Janssen Pharms, Inc. v. Mylan Lab'y Ltd.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Findings Of Non-Obviousness And Infringement Of Method Of Treatment Patent Claiming Dosing Regimen For Long-Acting Antipsychotic Injectable file 13376 16612 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-cafc-found-machine-learning-patents-ineligible-subject-matter-under-101 2025-04-28 0.5 13376 Blog The CAFC Found Machine Learning Patents Ineligible Subject Matter Under %26sect;%26nbsp;101 16628 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-04-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50744/[IP] Recentive Analytics v. Fox Corp.pdf File: The CAFC Found Machine Learning Patents Ineligible Subject Matter Under %26sect;%26nbsp;101 file 13376 16628 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-cafc-holds-that-ipr-estoppel-does-not-shield-patentees-from-system-prior-art 2025-05-12 0.5 13376 Blog The CAFC Holds That IPR Estoppel Does Not Shield Patentees From System Prior Art 16673 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-05-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50790/[IP] Ingenico Inc. v. IOENGINE, LLC.pdf File: The CAFC Holds That IPR Estoppel Does Not Shield Patentees From System Prior Art file 13376 16673 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/non-speculative-evidence-of-irreparable-harm-is-required-for-preliminary-injunction 2025-05-19 0.5 13376 Blog Non-Speculative Evidence Of Irreparable Harm Is Required For Preliminary Injunction 16705 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-05-19 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50814/[IP] Incyte Corp. v. Sun Pharm. Indus. Ltd.pdf File: Non-Speculative Evidence Of Irreparable Harm Is Required For Preliminary Injunction file 13376 16705 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-holds-that-conception-does-not-require-certainty-of-success 2025-05-27 0.5 13376 Blog Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Holds That Conception Does Not Require Certainty of Success 16721 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-05-27 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/50866/22-1653.OPINION.5-12-2025_2512679.pdf File: Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Holds That Conception Does Not Require Certainty of Success file 13376 16721 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-ptabrsquos-implicit-and-incorrect-claim-construction 2025-06-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects PTAB%26rsquo;s Implicit And Incorrect Claim Construction Of %26ldquo;Between 1 And 10%26rdquo; 16759 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-06-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51160/[IP] Sigray, Inc. v. Carl Zeiss X-Ray Microscopy, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects PTAB%26rsquo;s Implicit And Incorrect Claim Construction Of %26ldquo;Between 1 And 10%26rdquo; file 13376 16759 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-patent-trial-and-appeal-board-decision 2025-06-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Trial And Appeal Board Decision, Finding Claims Of Patents Covering CRISPR Guide RNA Technology As Anticipated And Obvious 16779 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-06-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51190/[IP 1] Agilent Techs. Inc. v. Synthego Corp.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Trial And Appeal Board Decision, Finding Claims Of Patents Covering CRISPR Guide RNA Technology As Anticipated And Obvious file 13376 16779 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/district-court-claim-construction-of-branched-alkyl-in-mrna-vaccine-patent-dispute-affirmed 2025-06-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Of %26quot;Branched Alkyl%26quot; In mRNA Vaccine Patent Dispute 16784 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-06-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51191/[IP 2] Alynylam Pharms., Inc v. Moderna, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms District Court%26rsquo;s Claim Construction Of %26quot;Branched Alkyl%26quot; In mRNA Vaccine Patent Dispute file 13376 16784 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-clarifies-nexus-standard-for-secondary-consideration-licensing-evidence 2025-06-23 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Clarifies Nexus Standard For Secondary Consideration Licensing Evidence 16816 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-06-23 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51206/[IP] Ancora Techs., Inc. v. Roku, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Clarifies Nexus Standard For Secondary Consideration Licensing Evidence file 13376 16816 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-vacates-300m-damages-award-due-to-flawed-verdict-form 2025-07-01 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Vacates $300 Million Damages Award Due To Flawed Verdict Form 16843 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-07-01 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51227/[IP] Optis Cellular Tech., LLC v. Apple Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Vacates $300 Million Damages Award Due To Flawed Verdict Form file 13376 16843 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/the-federal-circuit-rejects-ptab-use-of-traditional-construction 2025-07-14 0.5 13376 Blog The Federal Circuit Rejects PTAB%26rsquo;s Use Of Traditional Construction Of %26ldquo;Consisting Essentially Of%26rdquo; 16903 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-07-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51261/[IP] Eye Therapies, LLC v. Slayback Pharma, LLC.pdf File: The Federal Circuit Rejects PTAB%26rsquo;s Use Of Traditional Construction Of %26ldquo;Consisting Essentially Of%26rdquo; file 13376 16903 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/overlapping-range-presumption-not-applied 2025-07-21 0.5 13376 Blog Overlapping Range Presumption Not Applied Given Specified Doses Administered At Specified Times 16957 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-07-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51278/[IP 1] Janssen Pharms., Inc. v. Teva Pharms. USA, Inc.pdf File: Overlapping Range Presumption Not Applied Given Specified Doses Administered At Specified Times file 13376 16957 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-invalidates-patent-for-angioplasty-catheter 2025-07-21 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Invalidates Patent For Angioplasty Catheter Based On Applicant Admitted Prior Art 16958 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-07-21 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51279/[IP 2] Shockwave Med., Inc. v. Cardiovascular Sys., Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Invalidates Patent For Angioplasty Catheter Based On Applicant Admitted Prior Art file 13376 16958 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/non-application-of-interference-estoppel-by-ptab 2025-07-28 0.5 13376 Blog Non-Application Of Interference Estoppel By PTAB In An IPR Institution Decision Found To Be Unreviewable 16994 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-07-28 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51299/[IP] IGT v. Zynga Inc.pdf File: Non-Application Of Interference Estoppel By PTAB In An IPR Institution Decision Found To Be Unreviewable file 13376 16994 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/evidence-exclusion-and-daubert-motion-denials-must-be-supported-by-valid-legal-rule 2025-08-04 0.5 13376 Blog Evidence Exclusion And Daubert Motion Denials Must Be Supported By Valid Legal Rule And Reasoning; Damage Calculation Must Account For Patents Not Asserted In The Case 17036 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-08-04 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51360/[IP] Jiaxing Super Lighting Elec. Appliance, Co. v. CH Lighting Tech. Co., Ltd.pdf File: Evidence Exclusion And Daubert Motion Denials Must Be Supported By Valid Legal Rule And Reasoning; Damage Calculation Must Account For Patents Not Asserted In The Case file 13376 17036 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-issues-key-ruling-on-collateral-estoppel-and-patent-invalidity 2025-08-11 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Issues Key Ruling On Collateral Estoppel And Patent Invalidity 17057 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-08-11 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51372/[IP] Kroy IP Holdings, LLC v. Groupon, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Issues Key Ruling On Collateral Estoppel And Patent Invalidity file 13376 17057 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-patent-invalidity 2025-08-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Invalidity, Emphasizes Need For Substantive Expert Testimony 17098 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-08-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51408/[IP 1] Wilco Marsh Buggies %26 Draglines, Inc. v. Weeks Marine, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Patent Invalidity, Emphasizes Need For Substantive Expert Testimony file 13376 17098 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/claims-of-selectorized-dumbbell-weight-patent-not-directed-to-an-abstract-idea 2025-08-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Claims Of Selectorized Dumbbell Weight Patent Not Directed To An Abstract Idea 17099 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-08-25 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51409/[IP 2] Powerblock Holdings, Inc. v. iFit, Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Claims Of Selectorized Dumbbell Weight Patent Not Directed To An Abstract Idea file 13376 17099 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptab-in-first-post-aia-derivation-proceeding-review 2025-09-15 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB In First Post-AIA Derivation Proceeding Review 17141 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-09-15 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51469/[IP] Global Health Solutions v. Selner.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB In First Post-AIA Derivation Proceeding Review file 13376 17141 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/a-defendant-cannot-withhold-evidence-but-argue-that-plaintiff-cannot-meet-its-burden-of-infringement 2025-09-22 0.5 13376 Blog A Defendant Cannot Withhold Evidence Or Contend Evidence Is Unnecessary During Discovery But Argue At Trial That Plaintiff Cannot Meet Its Burden Of Infringement For Lack Of Such Evidence 17164 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-09-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51477/[IP 1] Magēmā Tech. LLC v. Phillips 66.pdf File: A Defendant Cannot Withhold Evidence Or Contend Evidence Is Unnecessary During Discovery But Argue At Trial That Plaintiff Cannot Meet Its Burden Of Infringement For Lack Of Such Evidence file 13376 17164 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-further-clarifies-the-meaning-of-prevailing-party 2025-09-22 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Further Clarifies The Meaning Of %26ldquo;Prevailing Party%26rdquo; 17165 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-09-22 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51478/[IP 2] Future Link Sys., LLC v. Realtek Semiconductor Corp.pdf File: Federal Circuit Further Clarifies The Meaning Of %26ldquo;Prevailing Party%26rdquo; file 13376 17165 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-requires-comparison-of-similar-not-identical-goods-under-the-sixth-dupont-factor 2025-09-29 0.5 13376 Blog Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Requires Comparison Of Similar, Not Identical, Goods Under The Sixth DuPont Factor 17192 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-09-29 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51595/[IP] Apex Bank v. CC Serve Corp.pdf File: Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Requires Comparison Of Similar, Not Identical, Goods Under The Sixth DuPont Factor file 13376 17192 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-reverses-patent-and-trademark 2025-10-06 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Reverses Patent And Trademark Infringement Findings And Vacates Trade Dress And Willfulness Findings 17212 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-10-06 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51622/[IP] Focus Prods. Grp. Int'l v. Kartri Sales Co..pdf File: Federal Circuit Reverses Patent And Trademark Infringement Findings And Vacates Trade Dress And Willfulness Findings file 13376 17212 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-jmol-of-no-damages-in-surgical-stapler-patent-dispute 2025-10-14 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms JMOL Of No Damages In Surgical Stapler Patent Dispute 17218 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-10-14 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51648/[IP] Rex Medical, L.P. v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms JMOL Of No Damages In Surgical Stapler Patent Dispute file 13376 17218 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/uspto-proposes-ptab-rule-revisions-to-curb-serial-and-parallel-challenges 2025-10-20 0.5 13376 Blog USPTO Proposes PTAB Rule Revisions To Curb Serial And Parallel Challenges, Bolster Patent Reliability 17245 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-10-20 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51664/[IP] PTAB IPR Rule Revision.pdf File: USPTO Proposes PTAB Rule Revisions To Curb Serial And Parallel Challenges, Bolster Patent Reliability file 13376 17245 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/consistent-and-interchangeable-use-of-terms-leads-to-implicit-lexicographic-definition 2025-11-03 0.5 13376 Blog Consistent And Interchangeable Use Of Terms Leads To Implicit Lexicographic Definition 17327 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-11-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51789/[IP 1] Aortic Innovations LLC v. Edwards Lifesciences Corp.pdf File: Consistent And Interchangeable Use Of Terms Leads To Implicit Lexicographic Definition file 13376 17327 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-the-itcrsquos-finding-of-invalidity-of-water-filter-patent 2025-11-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms The ITC%26rsquo;s Finding Of Invalidity Of Water-Filter Patent 17328 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-11-03 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51790/[IP 2] Brita LP v. ITC.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms The ITC%26rsquo;s Finding Of Invalidity Of Water-Filter Patent file 13376 17328 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-grapples-with-standard-for-judicial-correction-of-patent-claim-language 2025-11-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Grapples With Standard For Judicial Correction Of Patent Claim Language 17373 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-11-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51904/IP - Canatex Completion Solutions, Inc. v. Wellmatics, LLC, et al..pdf File: Federal Circuit Grapples With Standard For Judicial Correction Of Patent Claim Language file 13376 17373 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-ptabs-obviousness-rulings-on-mercks-oral-cladribine-ms-regimen-and-clarifies-the-by-another-prior-art-standard 2025-11-17 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Rulings On Merck%26rsquo;s Oral Cladribine MS Regimen And Clarifies The %26ldquo;By Another%26rdquo; Prior Art Standard 17375 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-11-17 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51911/Merck Serono S.A. v. Hopewell Pharma Ventures, Inc..pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB%26rsquo;s Obviousness Rulings On Merck%26rsquo;s Oral Cladribine MS Regimen And Clarifies The %26ldquo;By Another%26rdquo; Prior Art Standard file 13376 17375 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-continues-its-strict-review-of-genus-claims-and-reverses-lack-of-written-description-verdict 2025-11-25 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Continues Its Strict Review Of Genus Claims And Reverses Lack Of Written Description Verdict 17408 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-11-24 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/51970/IP - Duke v. Sandoz.pdf File: Federal Circuit Continues Its Strict Review Of Genus Claims And Reverses Lack Of Written Description Verdict file 13376 17408 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-estoppel-and-expired-patent-arguments-and-affirms-finding-of-anticipation 2025-12-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects Estoppel And Expired Patent Arguments And Affirms Finding of Anticipation 17476 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-12-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/52015/In Re GESTURE TECHNOLOGY PARTNERS, LLC.pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects Estoppel And Expired Patent Arguments And Affirms Finding of Anticipation file 13376 17476 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-indefiniteness-and-noninfringement-of-intelligent-distribution-network-patents 2025-12-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Indefiniteness And Noninfringement Of Intelligent Distribution Network Patents 17477 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-12-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/52014/AKAMAI TECHNOLOGIES, INC. v. MEDIAPOINTE, INC., AMHC, INC.1.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Indefiniteness And Noninfringement Of Intelligent Distribution Network Patents file 13376 17477 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-rejects-mandamus-petition-challenging-discretionary-denials 2025-12-16 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Rejects Mandamus Petition Challenging Discretionary Denials 17484 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2025-12-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/52012/In Re MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC..pdf File: Federal Circuit Rejects Mandamus Petition Challenging Discretionary Denials file 13376 17484 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-of-appeals-for-the-federal-circuit-denies-appeal-from-a-district-court-ordering-an-8-million-bond 2026-01-12 0.5 13376 Blog Court of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Denies Appeal From A District Court Ordering An $8 Million Bond Under Idaho%26rsquo;s Bad Faith Assertions Of Patent Infringement Act 17564 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2026-01-12 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/52042/IP - MICRON v. LONGHORN.pdf File: Court of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Denies Appeal From A District Court Ordering An $8 Million Bond Under Idaho%26rsquo;s Bad Faith Assertions Of Patent Infringement Act file 13376 17564 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/court-of-appeals-for-the-federal-circuit-invalidates-in-store-product-locator-patents-as-abstract-under-101 2026-02-17 0.5 13376 Blog Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Invalidates In-Store Product Locator Patents As Abstract Under %26sect; 101 18701 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2026-02-16 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/53134/INNOVAPORT v. TARGET.pdf File: Court Of Appeals For The Federal Circuit Invalidates In-Store Product Locator Patents As Abstract Under %26sect; 101 file 13376 18701 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-affirms-summary-judgment-of-non-infringement-for-failure-to-prove-structural-equivalence-under-112f 2026-03-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment Of Non Infringement For Failure To Prove Structural Equivalence Under %26sect; 112(f) 19726 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2026-03-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/54165/GET v. SONY.pdf File: Federal Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment Of Non Infringement For Failure To Prove Structural Equivalence Under %26sect; 112(f) file 13376 19726 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/federal-circuit-finds-claims-as-a-whole-directed-to-patent-eligible-non-naturally-occurring-composition 2026-03-02 0.5 13376 Blog Federal Circuit Finds Claims as a Whole Directed to Patent Eligible Non-Naturally Occurring Composition 19727 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2026-03-02 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/54166/REGENXBIO v SAREPTA THERAPEUTICS.pdf File: Federal Circuit Finds Claims as a Whole Directed to Patent Eligible Non-Naturally Occurring Composition file 13376 19727 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/doj-and-uspto-urge-courts-to-consider-injunctions-for-nonpracticing-patentees-under-ebay-emphasize-irreparable-harm-and-the-limits-of-monetary-remedies 2026-03-10 0.5 13376 Blog DOJ And USPTO Urge Courts To Consider Injunctions For Non‑Practicing Patentees Under eBay; Emphasize Irreparable Harm And The Limits Of Monetary Remedies 19782 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 2026-03-10 0.3 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/siteFiles/54184/COLLISION COMMUNICATIONS, INC. v. SAMSUNG.pdf File: DOJ And USPTO Urge Courts To Consider Injunctions For Non‑Practicing Patentees Under eBay; Emphasize Irreparable Harm And The Limits Of Monetary Remedies file 13376 19782 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9 https://www.lit-ip.aoshearman.com/cookie-policy 2025-12-03 1.0 13477 Site Page Cookie Policy 0 066FA82C-88C5-4DCE-A50D-0E8678FAEFA9